Tag Set reopened

Oct 04, 2013 13:40

The tag set has been reopened for vetting. As it was unclear which problems should go in the form, the form will remain closed and all problems should be noted in the comments of this post ( Read more... )

admin, tag set review

Leave a comment

Comments 527

elliemurasaki October 4 2013, 17:55:43 UTC
Ember Days (2013) is under video games, not movies.

Reply

hhertzof October 4 2013, 18:05:55 UTC
Fixed.

Reply


debirlfan October 4 2013, 17:59:38 UTC
Tony Kanaan is listed under both Indycar RPF and Formula 1 RPF - to the best of my knowledge, he should only be under Indycar.
Holmes on Homes RPF is listed twice under RPF with the same characters.

Reply

hhertzof October 4 2013, 18:17:51 UTC
Fixed.

Reply


not_unwise October 4 2013, 18:01:22 UTC
Ultimate Spider-Man, Ultimate Fantastic 4, Ultimate X-Men and The Ultimates have all be merged into "Marvel Ultimates" even though they're all separate series with different characters and different readers. This startles me because it's generally understood that comic book series are separate, and things that overlap like Batgirl and Red Robin were still left separate after being nominated separately ( ... )

Reply

grey_bard October 4 2013, 18:33:41 UTC
Seconded. Marvel Ultimates is a very specific comic. A very NSFW comic with canon cannibalism by a major character. Ultimate Spider-man is safe for kids and stars a thirteen year old. Fans of one are generally a different group than fans of the other. Ideally they should not be merged. If you really feel you must merge them, may I suggest the title-neutral official Marvel name for that universe - the Marvel Ultimate Universe?

Reply

nopejr October 4 2013, 18:35:53 UTC
I was about to post this exact same thing.

Reply

dudski October 4 2013, 20:32:31 UTC
This. As I said in the previous post: If I hadn't nommed UC:SM myself and seen the changes that were made to my nom, I wouldn't have any idea characters like Miles and Ganke were even in this year, because there's no reason anyone would think to look for them under Marvel Ultimates ( ... )

Reply


bookshop October 4 2013, 18:02:30 UTC

Okay idk if this will help, but Fresne - Marie de France might refer to this series of original fiction / historical RPF posted by the AO3 user fresne.

but i can't find any mention of conrad in her works either. Sorry.

Reply

quillori October 4 2013, 18:21:27 UTC
I'd wondered if whoever nominated Fresne and Eliduc had also nominated Jean Renart's Guillaume de Dole and accidentally put Conrad under the wrong fandom, but now the tag set is reopened I don't see it there, so apparently not.

Reply

vana_tuivana October 5 2013, 22:44:36 UTC
Le Fresne is listed as a character under the fandom, so I'm thinking the nominator did mean the lai by Marie de France.

I didn't nominate this fandom, but my thought is that "Conrad" is most likely an autocorrect error for La Codre.

Reply


(The comment has been removed)

hhertzof October 4 2013, 18:17:37 UTC
This is the tag set bug at work. The tag set requires tags be unique, but once they're through they pick up underlying wrangling relationships. We cleared out a duplicate Lewis tag, leaving the canonical in both fandoms, but didn't need to do that for Laura.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up