i don't have to fear it

Jul 28, 2010 14:12

You guys, I don't understand how badfic is bad in exactly the same ways in EVERY SINGLE FANDOM I'VE EVER READ. To wit ( Read more... )

i won't read your fic if, writing: pov, writing: on language

Leave a comment

Comments 116

de_nugis July 28 2010, 18:17:08 UTC
You have just made me want to sit down with my scarily extensive collection of obscure Latin epics and collect really stupid epithets and write Sam/Dean fic in which I don't use their actual names even once. It will be bad enough to make your orbs pop out.

Reply

musesfool July 28 2010, 18:31:16 UTC
Ahahahahahaha! You should totally do that.

Reply


reddwarfer July 28 2010, 18:19:16 UTC
Word. So much word that there's more WORD here than there is a dictionary.

Amen to that. Fucking word orbs, especially.

Reply

musesfool July 28 2010, 18:31:37 UTC
I know! ORBS! WHO THOUGHT THAT WAS A GOOD IDEA?

Reply

reddwarfer July 28 2010, 19:04:20 UTC
AND IT'S NEVER A PRIMARY COLOUR. IT'S ALWAYS CERULEAN OR OBSIDIAN OR AQUAMARINE!!!!

(I tend to hate when it's: "I want to eat corndogs," he laughed.) Because it's not easy to laugh out dialogue.

Reply

musesfool July 28 2010, 20:12:43 UTC
Primary colors are for the great unwashed. Pfft.

And yeah, that's not quite as irritating to me as the other stuff, but yeah. Also, people hissing things that have no sibilant sounds in them. I know what it's trying to say, but I have that moment of, "wait."

Reply


celtprincess13 July 28 2010, 18:25:15 UTC
You know what's currently driving me nuts? Fic in the Leverage fandom because in one scene we'll have Eliot, Hardison, Parker, the hitter, the hacker, the thief, the blonde, the long-haired man, the taller man, the computer wiz, the fighter, the pickpocket...it goes on and on and on and the only thing I'm thinking is damn, who knew you could fit that many people in one bed? And I know very well that isn't what the writer is meaning.

husking (dear god, if you are not shucking corn, please to not be using "husk" as a verb; this has rapidly moved up my list of pet peeves)

AMEN, SISTER. Preach it! Every time I see "he husked", I'm waiting for someone to get out the boiling water and the butter. It does not add the tone of sexy they appear to be going for.

Reply

musesfool July 28 2010, 18:33:10 UTC
the only thing I'm thinking is damn, who knew you could fit that many people in one bed? And I know very well that isn't what the writer is meaning.

Exactly! I mean, there are times and places to play with people's names and how they refer to themselves or each other - the switch from Sam to Sammy, or from Moony to Remus for example - that has meaning in a story. But just randomly using a lot of descriptors because you don't want to repeat the person's name a lot and can't figure out the pronouns is just poor writing.

Every time I see "he husked", I'm waiting for someone to get out the boiling water and the butter. It does not add the tone of sexy they appear to be going for.

SERIOUSLY!

Reply

spiralleds July 28 2010, 23:08:30 UTC
I am now having thoughts of fic that involve something along the lines of Sam husking Dean's manhood to orgasm.

Reply

(The comment has been removed)


kjfri July 28 2010, 18:37:04 UTC
I love you for saying this because as a non-writer, I don't feel right stifling other's creativity...but you, as their peer, can point out these truly annoying badfic habits. This medium-build-hazel-eyed reader thanks you profusely, she said.

Reply

musesfool July 28 2010, 19:46:50 UTC
I don't think it's stifling creativity to point out that there are POV errors etc. I mean, I know fandom seems to think that's the case, so you're taking your virtual life in your hands in some cases, but really, some things are just annoying and jar a reader out of the story.

Reply


effervescent July 28 2010, 18:39:34 UTC
Hee. This stuff annoys me as well (though god, I find myself doing it sometimes) and this entry made me laugh :D It's like with H/D, in Harry Potter fandom... It was always 'the blond' and 'the dark haired boy', etc.

My favourite (out of fandom) are the porny-romance novels that try to make it more legit by using comparisons like 'hidden garden' and 'love juices', though that's a whole different type of writing, haha.

Reply

musesfool July 28 2010, 19:47:31 UTC
My favourite (out of fandom) are the porny-romance novels that try to make it more legit by using comparisons like 'hidden garden' and 'love juices', though that's a whole different type of writing, haha.

Yeah, I didn't even want to get into "her molten womanly core" and "his proud manroot". WTF?

Reply

effervescent July 28 2010, 19:51:57 UTC
molten womanly core

*dead* hahaha, y'know, you'd think that the person involved in that sort of situation might be worried about getting lava on their hands/other parts of their anatomy... And man root makes me think of planting, and a garden of penises (penii?) isn't something that appeals.

Also, icon love!!

Reply

musesfool July 28 2010, 20:19:51 UTC
This is one of the icons I've had the longest. I &heart; Allison Janney.

I imagine fandom would LOVE a magic garden of penii.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up