A long review of Deathly Shallows

[aloysiusweasley]

Hi there, guys! Not sure if the comm is still up and running, but if any of you are interested, I did a looong...well, it's more of a list than anything else, but you'll get the idea.

175 Things I Hated About Deathly Hallows:

Part 1: http://aloysiusweasley.livejournal.com/47788.html
Part 2: http://aloysiusweasley.livejournal.com/48043.html

Also, as if

Comments

[aloysiusweasley]

Well, I had fun writing it. Enjoy! :D

[scatteredlogic]

While I didn't agree with you on everything, I agreed with about 95% of the instances you listed. The more I think about DH, the more tired I become. Therefore, I expect I'll just continue to splash about in the shallow fanon end of the pool; I'll be much happier that way. ;)

[aloysiusweasley]

I definitely didn't expect everybody to agree, everybody was looking to read it for different things. ;)

I think I'll be doing the same - the lack of logic in this book along with the rabid (although admittedly currently quiet) sums of fans means getting in the thick of things can be hazardous. :D

[catherinecookmn]

Here's my own take on the thing.

[aloysiusweasley]

Thanks! I really love being sent links instead of stumbling around to find all the takes on DH - it's really wierd how quiet fandom is on this (thankfully) final book. *scoots off to go read*