Last call for corrections

Oct 06, 2013 17:50

We're still taking corrections and duplicate character fixes on the tag set correction post. We'll be closing that post at Noon, EDT. Any outstanding inquiries (at the moment: Conrad, Rachel Wiseman, Eventuality - Trevor Samora, and Vikram) will be rejected at that time ( Read more... )

admin, tag set review

Leave a comment

Comments 34

nnozomi October 6 2013, 23:55:58 UTC
I am not the original nominator, but I am pretty sure that Vikram is a character in Alif the Unseen (Willow Wilson, book fandom), since there is a major character of that name in the book, and it currently shows three other characters nominated. If I'm off base, apologies.

Reply

hhertzof October 7 2013, 11:27:39 UTC
Thank you. That seems likely as all the other tags from that book ended up in the bin. I just couldn't find him.

Reply


debirlfan October 7 2013, 04:46:08 UTC
Just noticed that under "The Neighbors 2012" Larry Bird is listed twice - once as Larry Bird and once as Larry Bird (The Neighbors). Suggest removing the first, as it's likely to be confused with RPF of the basketball player. Thanks.

Reply

hhertzof October 7 2013, 11:28:36 UTC
Fixing, thanks.

Reply


cordialcount October 7 2013, 04:59:41 UTC
The characters appear to be dissociated from Honou no Miraju | Mirage of Blaze. They were Kadowaki Ayako | Kakizaki Haruie, Naoe Nobutsuna, and Takaya Ougi | Kagetora Uesugi.

Reply

hhertzof October 7 2013, 11:29:07 UTC
Found them in the unassociated bin. Not sure how they ended up there, but they'll be put back where they belong. Thanks.

Reply

undomielregina October 7 2013, 16:00:14 UTC
That probably happened because the canonical was changed in response to a support request (the transliteration was incorrect.) The new canonical is "炎の蜃気楼[ミラージュ] | Honoo no Mirage | Mirage of Blaze"

Reply


disc_losure October 7 2013, 05:54:09 UTC
One more minor correction that seems to be unaddressed, particularly since comments have been locked on the previous post. Gwen Stacy is still missing from the character list for the fandom which the mods decided to rename to Ultimate Comics Spider-Man. For the reasons mentioned here, here, here, here, here, here, here, and here she's a valid character, who was properly nominated in a canon that she appears in, and who has an appropriately small number of tag uses on AO3.

To keep her out at this point really can't be considered anything other than a showing of bad faith and is certainly not in the spirit of Yuletide.

Reply


dhampyresa October 7 2013, 10:09:04 UTC
Since you seem unwilling to listen to the fans on the Gwen Stacy issue, let me illustrate that the creators do not differentiate between clone!Gwen and original!Gwen either.

In January of 2013, I went to the Angoulême International Comics Festival. So did Sara Pichelli. Sara Pichelli draws Ultimate Spider-Man and Panini publishes the French edition. I was lucky enough to get her to draw me a sketch. I asked for Gwen Stacy and she did not ask me to disambiguate. Here's proof, but at this point, I don't expect anything to make any difference, given the way you've treated us this the beginning of this debacle.

Instead, I'll just post the sketch, with "For Yuletiders!" were my real name is in the original, so that people who want can have a little Gwen in their Yuletide.


... )

Reply


Leave a comment

Up