The tag set has been reopened for vetting. As it was unclear which problems should go in the form, the form will remain closed and all problems should be noted in the comments of this post
( Read more... )
So you locked comments on the original post, so I'm going to give you my complaint here, because seriously? Silencing people who have the audacity to point out your mistakes when you have continuously fucked up and fucked us over? That is so far from cool we're on the sun. You don't have to respond to any of us. You don't have to actually do anything. You can stand by your decisions til the end of time. But at least let us make our complaints. You have handled this so abysmally that numerous comic fans now feel pretty unwelcome. The least you can do is let us comment on it.
So here is mine:
ETA: Given all the comments asking the same questions, we have decided to address it here, rather than answering separately. In Ultimate Comics Spider-Man, only Gwen's clone appears, not Gwen herself. Thus she is considered a separate character. Therefore this decision stands.
Oh goodie. I take back my comment above about the changing of Spider-Man (ultimateverse) to just Ultimate Comics: Spider-Man not being a big deal. If you are using the
( ... )
Ultimate Spider-Man and Ultimate Comics: Spider-Man are the same fandom. No exceptions. They are considered the same comic title in every way it matters here.
Yes, this exactly! Given that the mod stance on every nomination except this one seems to be 'leave it as it was nominated' (cf. this comment, in which MasterChef US and MasterChef Australia, two inarguably different series, are being left combined as nominated), I have no idea why Spider-Man (Ultimateverse) is not being applied to the same standard, when Ultimate Spider-Man and Ultimate Comics: Spider-Man are two volumes of the same series. In the interests of even a modicum of fairness and consistency, I sincerely ask that the Spider-Man (Ultimateverse) fandom be left (or reinstated) as nominated
( ... )
So here is mine:
ETA: Given all the comments asking the same questions, we have decided to address it here, rather than answering separately. In Ultimate Comics Spider-Man, only Gwen's clone appears, not Gwen herself. Thus she is considered a separate character. Therefore this decision stands.
Oh goodie. I take back my comment above about the changing of Spider-Man (ultimateverse) to just Ultimate Comics: Spider-Man not being a big deal. If you are using the ( ... )
Reply
Yes, this exactly! Given that the mod stance on every nomination except this one seems to be 'leave it as it was nominated' (cf. this comment, in which MasterChef US and MasterChef Australia, two inarguably different series, are being left combined as nominated), I have no idea why Spider-Man (Ultimateverse) is not being applied to the same standard, when Ultimate Spider-Man and Ultimate Comics: Spider-Man are two volumes of the same series. In the interests of even a modicum of fairness and consistency, I sincerely ask that the Spider-Man (Ultimateverse) fandom be left (or reinstated) as nominated ( ... )
Reply
Leave a comment