S8 #36

Sep 01, 2010 21:05

If you haven't seen a summary yet,
Read more... )

fandom, whinging, random, rants

Leave a comment

Comments 54

shapinglight September 1 2010, 20:10:16 UTC
:hugs:, love. I feel your pain. So much so that I don't want to post at all. Can I suggest you flock this, though? No point in giving unfriendly readers even more of a happy.

Reply

quinara September 1 2010, 20:21:44 UTC
*hugs back* I suppose only time will tell whether or not it's salvageable, but it seems very gloomy right now.

As for flocking, I suppose I should, but part of me hopes this reaches Joss's inbox down the Bangel KGB grapevine. Not that it would give him any sort of pause, but it would be nice to know the pixels had reached his eyes.

Reply

shapinglight September 1 2010, 21:57:15 UTC
I don't think Joss ever sees any of this stuff, no matter how much the extremist Bangels might like to believe he reads their arse kissing. At most, it'll get back to Scott Allie, who is pretty blameless, this issue being entirely Joss-penned.

Reply

quinara September 1 2010, 22:04:32 UTC
It's true, but presumably he and Scott chat over tea coffee or something...

*sigh* I just get stuck thinking, even if I am over-reacting and everything's going to be put 'right' and there's some form of S7-appropriate reconcilement, can it ever be worth it? I hate miscommunication!angst fic. The pay-off's always completely overshadowed by the misery beforehand.

Reply


penny_lane_42 September 1 2010, 20:11:09 UTC
I've reached the point where I just don't care about the comics anymore (loooong time coming), but that doesn't mean I don't think this was cheap of Joss.

Reply

quinara September 1 2010, 20:22:52 UTC
I always think I've stopped caring (Riley's one-shot? Didn't care a jot about that), but then it just smacks me harder. And it was very, very cheap.

Reply

fangfaceandrea September 2 2010, 22:04:35 UTC
me too.:(

I just want to step away but the spoilers and discussion... I did stop reading the issues so that's progress and I just deleted the entire S8 from my computer, but I still feel bitch-slappped by the whole thing.

Reply

quinara September 2 2010, 23:05:13 UTC
It's very unfair of something that's just bound sheets of paper!! :(

Reply


bogwitch September 1 2010, 20:15:24 UTC
Even putting the ships aside, the whole series is a pile of shit.

Reply

sueworld2003 September 1 2010, 20:20:26 UTC
Oh yes! Bags and bags of it.

Reply

bogwitch September 1 2010, 20:34:36 UTC
I've got wound up and I'm not really even in the same fandom.

Reply

quinara September 1 2010, 20:24:20 UTC
That's very true. It's like the bad-cheese trippy nightmare version of half-remembered badfic.

Reply


divine_atrytone September 1 2010, 22:02:07 UTC
Oh Lord. Do I really want to seek it out now?

Reply

quinara September 1 2010, 22:09:00 UTC
Who knows, maybe everything will be wonderful; but I'd at least wait for the TPB... (Have you read the spoilers?)

Reply


ladyofthelog September 2 2010, 10:33:23 UTC
Like Journey, my Spuffy love will go on and on and on.

If this was the show, I'd probably be pissed. For me, though, as it is, it's just one of many stories. I totally understand why other people are upset about it, but idk, I don't expect much of Joss.

Reply

quinara September 2 2010, 10:42:59 UTC
Oh, the Spuffy love will always be there with me! They aren't taking that yet (the bastards!).

I can't work out where I am with the comics. They don't feel 'real' to me, because I spend at least half of my time going 'this is all horrifically OOC' and failing to invest, but I think there's another part of me that sees this as what Joss would have done if there had been another season on TV, and my disappointment's reflected from that. For every wunderreunion of joy Bangel gets, Spuffy just seems to get these skated-over, half-arsed attempts at putting their two characters on the same page. I know I'm supposed to be enthused about Bangel stopping/destroying the world with their reunion and be sure that Spuffy are going to continue to interact while getting the job done, etc. etc. - but all I want is some time to be invested in them, like they actually matter.

*sigh* Sorry for the whinge - I think I need to write more fic...

Reply

ladyofthelog September 2 2010, 10:51:11 UTC
See, I think the complete lack of budget limitations has completely changed the course of the story. Joss would never have been able to make "Season 8" into S8 of the show. It would have been impossible. In a comic book, of course Mecha!Dawn vs. Giant!Dawn makes sense.

I would have been way less pissed if the B/A stuff happened on TV. You know why? Because Joss was a big part of the TV series, but the actors were also a huge part. If SMG and DB were onscreen, what was going on would probably have been completely transparent from the beginning. Also more interesting. Also SMG has a no-nudity clause in her contract. ;)

Sidenote: I like Willow in Season 8. I think I may be continuing to read the series just for her. Weird, because Willow is generally not one of my favorite characters.

Hey, everyone needs to whinge a bit now and then!. *hugs* I'm taking your suggestion and writing some now. Fic cures all ills.

Reply

quinara September 2 2010, 11:00:52 UTC
He might not have been able to do exactly the same sort of thing, but if we believe Joss that the emotional trajectory is the most important thing for him (though S8 has pulled that into question as well), then the shape of the story could easily have stayed the same. The plot could have been just as ill-structured, even if the components were slightly less ludicrous.

Considering B/A is apparently a case of 'drugs made them do the wacky, but it's still them, just souped up', I think I still would have been depressed. Because, obviously, Buffy Never Moved On and she is in exactly the same emotional place as she was in IWRY, two/three years after Chosen, and will go there at the slightest push.

As for Willow... She seems to me to be more of a Mary Sue than ever. I quite like Kennedy now, though, so it kind of irritates me more. ;)

Fic is the ultimate panacea. I also have boring work to do today, but I must get some of that it as well. Also some of my Darla vid. (Oh yes, Darla vid! To this song!! Though with a lot of the ( ... )

Reply


Leave a comment

Up