This might be a seriously silly question, but I just need to let it out: so what is exactly the more predominant thought on the whole Rose issue?
I mean, from where I am, no one really watches DW (no one I know, at least) so I have no clue as to what's the "popular" opinion on Rose. I've been force-feeding my best friend some New Who (she's seen a bit of S1 and S2) and she's not particularly fond of her. But that's one opinion out of a billion, I was just wondering what it's like over where you are?
It's not a silly question at all. And it really depends where you hang out. The corners of LJ which I frequent are occupied by mostly ardent Martha fans. But the non-LJ areas of the net that I frequent tend to be occupied by a lot of people who think Rose is the best thing since sliced bread and the "Ultimate Companion" in the whole of the Whoniver EVAH
( ... )
I can understand how people may believe that Rose is/was great, I really liked her in S1, after all. But S2? Nope. And after seeing S3 with Martha? Rose pales in comparison. But still, I can respect all the Rose love. I can't really say the same for RTD though, I've seen him on a few TW Declassifieds and some of the DW ones (I can't remember the name for it right now) and he just rubs me the wrong way sometimes. I'll shut up now before I get virtually kicked in the arse by someone out there, the internet is a brutal place :p
Actually you're pretty safe to say what you like on my LJ - not many of my FList are RTD supporters and anyone who's not on my FList will get their comments screened before I post them, so if they were rude to you, I'd delete the comment...
DW Confidentials, they're called. I confess I've yet to watch many of them (I only watched the "Smith and Jones" one and the one DT himself did for Blink when they aired) and although the "Confidential Cutdowns" are on the boxset, I've yet to watch them (way too busy writing !)
Comments 26
Only that I don't like Rose and don't think RTD is god.
That's a unpopular opinion?! :p
Reply
Reply
Won't happen to be the Rose/Doctor sections of the fandom would it?
Reply
Reply
I mean, from where I am, no one really watches DW (no one I know, at least) so I have no clue as to what's the "popular" opinion on Rose. I've been force-feeding my best friend some New Who (she's seen a bit of S1 and S2) and she's not particularly fond of her. But that's one opinion out of a billion, I was just wondering what it's like over where you are?
Reply
Reply
Reply
DW Confidentials, they're called. I confess I've yet to watch many of them (I only watched the "Smith and Jones" one and the one DT himself did for Blink when they aired) and although the "Confidential Cutdowns" are on the boxset, I've yet to watch them (way too busy writing !)
Reply
Leave a comment