Leave a comment

Comments 18

maeir April 8 2024, 01:11:05 UTC
my friend (who is a professional potter) is going to be so mad that elsa didn't win.

Reply

silverstarry April 8 2024, 01:33:44 UTC

I was really rooting for Elsa. I loved that she had a very specific aesthetic but her pieces each week didn't look the same. I also loved that she embraced using color.

Reply

maeir April 8 2024, 01:50:21 UTC
my friend said that it's just so obvious that she is the most accomplished potter, like she has the strongest skill set. she also likes her aesthetic.

Reply

tekan April 8 2024, 20:19:21 UTC
I agree, I really wasn't pleased with Jen's win, I think Elsa had a much stronger run.

Reply


mamashan April 8 2024, 01:35:35 UTC
Oh, thank god, I've been wanting to vent about this for days.

The judging was SO biased. Jen's final set was really underwhelming, and there was a huge effing crack in the cake stand, and they were all absolutely gushing over it. Elsa's set was beautiful, and Kiefer's was really stunning, but the feedback for theirs was so dismissive, particularly of Kiefer's. They were so clearly actively looking for flaws to point out, whereas they handwaved away the ones in Jen's. I'm not necessarily saying she didn't deserve to win, but I was so turned off by that final critique that I really lost interest in any future seasons of the Canadian version.

Reply

maeir April 8 2024, 01:51:47 UTC
her cakestand had a crack in it and she still won?! did everyone else have equally big flaws?

Reply

invisiblegirlx April 8 2024, 02:51:46 UTC
Neither of the other finalists had tea pots that poured properly. One wasn't glazed properly so it wasn't usable.

Reply

maeir April 8 2024, 05:16:49 UTC
ah, that makes sense then.

Reply


silverstarry April 8 2024, 02:03:02 UTC
You can watch all of the episodes on YouTube!
[Spoiler (click to open)]
episode 1 - episode post

episode 2 - episode post

episode 3 - episode post

episode 4 - episode post

episode 5 - episode post

episode 6 - episode post

episode 7 - episode post

episode 8

Reply

sarah_bw April 8 2024, 17:38:54 UTC
Thanks for this post! I'm looking forward to watching.

Reply


gingerywilson April 8 2024, 15:47:29 UTC
Justice for Elsa! Also if Jackie hadn't had that one bad week she would have walked away with the whole show rip

Reply

renegadewaltz April 9 2024, 14:32:49 UTC
Totally agree! I was genuinely surprised when she was eliminated.

Reply


chainblinger April 8 2024, 16:24:47 UTC
Legit thought Elsa was going to win it! Jen’s makes we’re always too on the safe side for me.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up