Spoilery Thoughts, Speculations and Notes on Names re: HBP

Jul 28, 2005 05:24

Okay. I finished HBP. Here are my thoughts, in no particular order.

Spoilers for HBP! )

harry potter, essays

Leave a comment

Comments 30

happiestwhen July 28 2005, 09:37:35 UTC
I really, really want Peter to use that silver hand to kill Fenrir Greyback. Fenrir isn't just creepy; he's a walking metaphor for child molestation.

Oh, I am so with you here. I am actually mildly disturbed by the way a good portion of fandom is jumping all over Fenrir like he's a sex symbol godsend from JKR. >_

Reply

lazy_neutrino July 28 2005, 09:39:43 UTC
Ugh. He's got matted hair and stinks of blood, sweat and dirt? Hardly beddable.

He does have good baddie-qualities, though - he's quite the nastiest thing she's written. Apart from Hermione in a bad mood :) I'm writing a Greyback-baddie fic now!

Reply

happiestwhen July 28 2005, 09:43:26 UTC
He's definitely the sort of character who's just meant for horrorific darkfic kinda stuff. Interesting would be a good word. Well, that and very psychologically demented.

I guess I'm just a little O.o about all the Fenrir love. But then, fandom has always tended toward the perverse and socially scorned sort of stuff... *shrug*

Reply

lazy_neutrino July 28 2005, 09:55:32 UTC
I know, but dirt! Sweat! Matted hair! Actually he reminds me of the werewolf in CS Lewis' 'Prince Caspian', which still has the power to scare me three decades after I first read it.

He's fascinating, certainly. Uncontrolled evil, whereas Lucius Malfoy, for example, is controlled evil (mostly). But he's a bogeyman all right.

Reply


underlucius July 28 2005, 09:53:36 UTC
1.Yep. DD is an Ex-Headmaster. Ceased to Be. I was surprised he wasn't impaled by spikes then trampled by Centaurs after he landed from the tower ( ... )

Reply

gehayi July 28 2005, 10:34:40 UTC
20. You have been in the fandom too long…. *giggles*

Yes. Yes, I have.

Reply


lazy_neutrino July 28 2005, 09:57:10 UTC
17. I don't want him to die - but he should - you are right. My jaw dropped the floor when she introduced not one but TWO possible paedophilic characters.

Two?

19. I felt sorry for the vampire here, actually! I loved that bit.

Reply

gehayi July 28 2005, 10:13:47 UTC
I think that the other one would be Slughorn...with his club and private parties for his "special students."

And yes, the poor vampire. Didn't seem to be having a very good time, did he?

Reply

lazy_neutrino July 28 2005, 13:00:15 UTC
Oh yes, of course. Ugh. Actually, I never saw Slughorn in a sexual way at all. I think I felt he was too lazy. Maybe a voyeur or procurer, though.

Reply


(The comment has been removed)

gehayi July 28 2005, 11:53:20 UTC
I think that Sirius might return as a Grim. He's constantly associated with them--not only by means of his Animagus form but also through his nickname, "Padfoot," which is what the Black Dog of Yorkshire is called. Black dogs, or devil dogs, are supernatural guardians; they protect treasure, or they protect those who are in grave danger of death.

I can see Sirius showing up as a Grim at the final battle to guard Harry. It would be like him.

As for Dumbledore...well, here's the sentence in question:

White smoke spiralled into the air and made strange shapes: Harry thought, for one heart-stopping moment, that he saw a phoenix fly joyfully into the blue, but next second the fire had vanished.

I'm just chalking this up to Harry's imagination. You can see pretty much anything you want to in clouds or smoke.

Reply

lazy_neutrino July 28 2005, 13:05:09 UTC
I can see Sirius showing up as a Grim at the final battle to guard Harry. It would be like him.

Did you ever read my 'A Surfeit of Wands', by the way? Just sayin'. As they say. Although it's not quite like that.

Reply

gehayi July 28 2005, 15:06:06 UTC
No, I didn't. But now I'm going to have to!

Reply


(The comment has been removed)

gehayi July 28 2005, 15:05:05 UTC
Sorry, but the R/T shippers have been wearing on my nerves lately. They also don't seem to grasp that because Sirius is dead, this doesn't mean that Remus and Sirius weren't lovers.

Or that Remus couldn't love Sirius AND Tonks. Hello, there is such a thing as bisexuality. (Even though I don't know a damned thing about it ( ... )

Reply


Leave a comment

Up