Comments | galadriella1: Intial Reaction to The Fires of Pompeii

galadriella1

Intial Reaction to The Fires of Pompeii

Apr 12, 2008 19:58

Er.... wow...

Donna Noble is going to be a hard companion to give up. Catherine Tate took a marvlous turn as Donna in this episode that almost moved me to tears when she begged the Doctor to go back for someone, and also, finally someone to rival his gob. Actually, I think Donna is very much like Jackie Tyler - straight talking, but has an ( Read more... )

spoilers, martha jones, rose tyler, s1:father's day, series four, s4:the fires of pompeii, reviews, s4:the stolen earth/journey's end, jackie tyler, s4:turn left, 10th doctor, donna noble, gallifrey

Comments 5

sunnytyler001 April 12 2008, 20:10:09 UTC

"Maybe he doesn't want to believe it."

I agree. It's too good to be true, he doesn't dare to hope Lucius was talking about his beloved Rose...

svanderslice April 12 2008, 22:20:13 UTC

hmm...going back to Gallifrey, that would be awesome! And it would make a lot of sense with this theme we keep seeing.

stargirl577 April 12 2008, 22:54:37 UTC

I agree - Donna is an amazing companion. I wasn't sure after Runaway Bride, but Catherine Tate is awesome. She is very believable and balancing to the Doctor.

hippiebanana132 April 13 2008, 02:08:11 UTC

Donna Noble is going to be a hard companion to give up. - God, you can say that again.

amberfocus April 13 2008, 02:48:56 UTC

I thought she was hard enough to give up after Runaway Bride, I've always loved her, but this episode just cemented it. When she said, "I bloody love you!" I was thinking the same thing about her at that moment! She's brilliant.

As for why he can't see Rose, he's said before he doesn't look directly into his own time line because the temptation to change things would be too great. So, that's most likely why he isn't seeing her in his future.