Leave a comment

Comments 15

elise_509 May 5 2010, 06:05:39 UTC
lol. I thought that too, when there was that shot of their hands. I may have snorted.

Jack/Sawyer...it's been so long, I will take anything. That felt golden to me. Remember the days when there were mangoes and snark and all that other good J/S stuff? *le sigh*

Miles is just...MIA. Who the heck knows.

Newsies FTW.

Hurley crying did bring it home. I thought that was a good decision and even though I wish Jack hadn't walked away to cry, it really is in line with his character. For all that that man cries, he doesn't do it that often actually in front of people if he can help it.

Kate squished Hurley, didn't she? Ah well. You're right, Sawyer will.

Reply

eponine119 May 5 2010, 06:14:58 UTC
I'm glad I wasn't the only one.

You're right, it was in character for Jack. It just...ruined the moment I wanted? and seemed cold somehow.

Reply

diandrahollman May 5 2010, 20:50:38 UTC
Has he ever sobbed right in front of people? I'm trying to recall all the meltdowns he's had in the past and it seems like he's always either wandered away to cry by himself or at least looked away like he didn't want people to see him break down (see the "your daddy loved you" conversation with Sawyer).

I'm sure there will be speculation on why he had to wander halfway into the ocean to cry. Like maybe he had a half-baked instinct to try to rescue the Kwons even though he knew they were beyond saving. Or maybe he was half-debating drowning himself because it's HIS FAULT ALL THESE PEOPLE KEEP DYING WAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHH.

Reply

eponine119 May 6 2010, 05:55:10 UTC
I'm not sure. I feel like he has, but I can't think of a specific instance, so maybe not.

I suspect he had to wander away because it made for a nicer shot. I should try to be less cynical, perhaps?

Reply


janie_tangerine May 5 2010, 09:15:07 UTC
Miles is off hiking in the jungle with Ben and Richard, and fuck knows what they've been up to. Finding an evil scheme to save the day I guess.

I... seriously. The Jack/Sawyer stuff made me happy, but.. Jesus. Apart from Jin and Sun which yeah, RANT POINTS, SAYID. Dammit. And damn, is Frank gone too? Because I thought he wasn't by the end but when he didn't show up on the beach... yeah. Hi, show, nice way to kill 60% of everyone I gave a damn about in just one episode.

Reply

eponine119 May 5 2010, 14:57:06 UTC
I completely forgot about Ben, and the jungle party.

And yeah. And was there a reason to kill them off? Eh...not so much.

Reply


elliotsmelliot May 5 2010, 12:36:28 UTC
Mr. E.S. made the Cameron reference in our household. I still cried.

Reply

eponine119 May 5 2010, 14:58:15 UTC
I'm sorry. I broke up when Hurley cried, so...it just took me longer. (I cry buckets at Titanic despite the cheesy emotional manipulation, too.)

Reply


alemyrddin May 5 2010, 15:22:51 UTC
Hurley crying felt heartbreaking and relieving at the same time, because it felt so incredibly real! (While this time Foxy took a little too long to produce a few tears).

I'm probably the only one who loved this episode. I mean - I found it sad, but good, save for the Titanic part.

Reply

eponine119 May 5 2010, 17:46:16 UTC
It was very real, that was why it got to me. Foxy...yeah.

I want to take bits of it that were good, but even on most of those the "really?" part outweighs it. For me. I'm glad you loved it.

Reply

diandrahollman May 6 2010, 20:05:58 UTC
I'm probably the only one who loved this episode.

Nope. It was sad, but that's not necessarily a bad thing. I've seen/heard a few people describe it as the best episode *ever*. Not sure I would go *that* far, but it was up there among the most powerful hours.

Reply

alemyrddin May 8 2010, 06:34:27 UTC
I've since read a few more positive replies. It seems that the one who have liked it are more than I thought. :)
I agree that it was powerful. And I can't stop myself enjoying (A LOT) those minutes of J/S interaction :)

Reply


uhzoomzip May 7 2010, 02:11:46 UTC
maybe miles is with richard alpert? i asked the same question about him during the episode - 'wtf is richard - did he die'?

the jin/sun thing was trite and predictable, but i still found myself moved by it... at least more than their 'reunion', which was so anti-climactic.

missed the last five minutes, but at least we got some jack/sawyer time!

Reply

eponine119 May 7 2010, 02:45:08 UTC
I guess Miles is with Richard. The other LJers say so, and they would know.

I wasn't unmoved, but I had a lot of other thoughts about it that were less than good.

But hooray for Jack and Sawyer.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up