MINERVA MCGONAGALL: 26 November, 1938

Apr 26, 2006 15:26

Grandmother:

One of the Hufflepuff boys told me that I wasn't a bad Chaser for a girl. I don't want that. Why does it have to have that 'for a girl' part added on to it? Why can't I just be a good player regardless of my sex? Eunice is the best seeker at Hogwarts and she's a girl. And all of the Holyhead Harpies are witches and they almost beat ( Read more... )

minerva_mcgonagall, 1938

Leave a comment

Comments 47

batbogey_hex April 26 2006, 23:51:32 UTC
*raises an eyebrow, grinning*
"For a girl," eh? Well, our team has a fair amount of excellent players, and our best Chasers have been girls.

*shrugs*
*as if it explains everything*
Boys.

Reply

_tartantabby_ April 26 2006, 23:59:01 UTC
Naughty!!!

*frowns*
Yeah. For a girl.
*lets out a bit of a sigh then smiles*
Oh? That's brilliant. I'd love to see a team at Hogwarts be all girls, like the Harpies. Can you imagine that?

*small laugh*
Yeah. Boys. Just because they can piss standing up, aye?

Reply

batbogey_hex April 27 2006, 03:19:09 UTC
*giggles* Hey, I'm in class and I can't speak. What else would I be doing? XD

*broad grin*
That would be brilliant. And if that team won the Cup too!

*amused roll of the eyes*
Indeed.
*thoughtfully*
But Gryffindor's been doing really well, even if there are boys on the team. Just, you know, sometimes they can be really obnoxious.

Reply

_tartantabby_ April 27 2006, 06:12:31 UTC
Some people read or do homework in these situations. I know it's an extreme path to take though.

*quiet snort*
They probably would too.

*nods*
Aye, we were brilliant in the game against Ravenclaw, despite our lads. Luckily most of them are accustomed to having girls on the team because of Eunice.

Reply


favourite_son April 27 2006, 08:21:17 UTC
*disdainfully*
Girls shouldn't be playing Quidditch at all, not if they've been brought up properly.

Reply

_tartantabby_ April 27 2006, 16:00:36 UTC
*eyes narrow and her shoulders square*
Just what do you mean 'brought up properly'?

Reply

favourite_son April 28 2006, 10:29:07 UTC
*small smirk at Minerva's change in posture*
Simply that Quidditch is no game for a lady.

Reply

_tartantabby_ April 28 2006, 18:26:22 UTC
And just how would you define a lady then? A simpering idiot who breeds every year?

Reply


rabastanlestran April 27 2006, 14:33:17 UTC
Well, that is rather silly - although, I suppose boys just assume they like Quidditch more because they babble on about it all the time and thusly must be better at it. Which is stupid, it would be like me saying I was good at Quidditch because I like cheering at the matches.

Reply

_tartantabby_ April 27 2006, 16:03:25 UTC
*takes a moment to comprehend what he's saying*
Oh aye. I think that's rather close to it.

Reply

rabastanlestran April 27 2006, 16:09:08 UTC
*smiles proudly*
See? That's why I think it's silly because everyone gets into fights about it but it's just a game and if you're good at it then you're good at it!

I don't think it matters if you're a girl or a boy in the end, just so long as you play well and you don't act like an idiot.

Reply

_tartantabby_ April 27 2006, 16:25:46 UTC
*nods enthusiastically*
That's what I think. Doesna matter what's between your legs, so long as you've got a good head on your shoulders and you ken how to play well.

Reply


gryffire_lily April 28 2006, 23:16:55 UTC
I think it's fantastic that you played Quidditch even though it perhaps wasn't that common for girls back then, Professor! Er... or was it acceptable back then among wizards?

I know Muggle girls didn't play football or cricket or participate in 'unladylike' activities back then. My mum said it changed during the war though, when all the men went off to fight and the women took up their duties. Was it the same for you?

Reply

_tartantabby_ April 28 2006, 23:30:44 UTC
*shakes her head*
It was more acceptable in the wizarding world than the Muggle world, certainly but still not heavily encouraged.

*expression flickers momentarily at the mention of the war*
Aye. There was quite the backlash after that for Muggle women in the next decade but that didn't seem to last very long. As your mother can attest to.

Reply

gryffire_lily April 28 2006, 23:44:06 UTC
*wrinkles her nose* Yeah, Mum told me some of her teachers said that she shouldn't bother going onto sixth form or university because she 'was just going to marry and have children' and she didn't need anymore education for that.

*grins*

But of course she didn't listen. She went on to university and and she got her doctorate in anthropology! She said that British society has changed a lot since she first started uni.

*curious* Has there been many changes in wizarding society since you've were in school?

Reply

_tartantabby_ April 28 2006, 23:58:08 UTC
*scowls at this*
Complete rubbish. Even if a woman chooses to do that, she should be as educated as she wishes.

*nods*
Your mother sounds like a woman I would love to meet. A pratical ambitious woman.

*lets out a slow breath*
We went through a war right after I finished. And I fear that wizarding society may have regressed in their attitudes toward people who were not purebloods.

Wow... *throws a letter bunny at you* Lily's mum takes tea with McGonagall.

Reply


brave_phoenix April 29 2006, 05:07:56 UTC
*loudly*
Yeah!! Magpies! Woooooo!!!

*enthusiastically*
Aren't they just the best team EVER?

Reply

_tartantabby_ April 30 2006, 16:53:31 UTC
*startles a bit at his enthusiasm but smiles*
Aye they are. They're my favourite team. My da takes me to their matches when he can.

Reply

brave_phoenix May 1 2006, 01:57:42 UTC
*grins broadly*
They're my favourite team, too!!!

*nods excitedly*
My dad takes me to matches, too!
*frowns*
Though my sister likes the Prides better...
*rolls eyes*
I try to tell her the Magpies are better...
But she just doesn't listen!

Reply


Leave a comment

Up