Comments | calixa: Better than the HP one.

calixa

Better than the HP one.

Apr 23, 2006 02:57

( This is how I feel about Tooth and Claw (plus my badass Torchwood theory!!) )

Comments 6

vertrauen April 23 2006, 07:19:23 UTC

Those two missing years Jack mentioned? Maybe those are the years he spent with Torchwood!

See, that was my theory ever since Torchwood became official. However, Rusty sorta side mentioned in the first Confidential of this year that Torchwood!Jack is post!PotW Jack and that he somehow got off the Game Station and made it back to present day Cardiff.

In all seriousness, I think Rusty and Crew missed the ball on that one. I think it would have been *awesome* to have Torchwood as Jack's missing years. It would have also explained the "no crossover" rule that Rusty has been so gung ho about, seeing as that Jack wouldn't have known The Doctor and Rose, and therefore no angst.

Woe.

>:( calixa April 23 2006, 07:32:39 UTC

Well, that's poo! *makes angry hissing noises*

spaced_oddity April 23 2006, 07:42:38 UTC

It's nice to read a positive reaction for this week's episode. Most of the ones I've seen have been quite negative. :(

Alkdsf;fg I am probably going to sob during next week's episode.

calixa April 23 2006, 08:20:10 UTC

That's weird, because I thought it was a lot better than New Earth and everyone seemed to love New Earth.

Yeah I'm getting the tissues ready ;_;

wheresmycow April 23 2006, 11:22:48 UTC

Oh, I like Tooth and Claw better than the last one--not so many plot holes, for one--but I thought that whole Torchwood ending was a cop-out. Surely there must have been a better way to fit in Torchwood than "Torchwood House" and "There will be an Institute...the Torchwood Institute!" (paraphrased) I mean, beat us over the head with it, why don't you?

I DO like your theory about Torchwood being Captain Jack's missing years, though. Would be a brilliant spin-off-but-not-quite-since-technically-he-wouldn't-have-met-them-yet.

majick April 23 2006, 22:45:14 UTC

I loved the show. It had everything - including naked!Billie Piper (well, nearly...)

And everything tied up within itself, which was nice. The writhers are clearly having fun, although I would have liked to see kung-fu monks doing their Matrix stuff, and the Doctor just oging "Ah... right," and running away in a different direction. That would have made it an A*, and not just an A.

And Sarah-Jane! And K9! Gah!