Leave a comment

Comments 20

00mina October 3 2009, 21:37:19 UTC
Least Favorite Icons
08 - the pic used is very cute, but the text adds nothing to it, looks a bit superfluous and squished on the top.
13 - Harry's glasses and the contours of his face are oversharpened/pixellated. It isn't very aesthetically pleasing.

Favorite Icon
16 - Interesting use of texture and text
17 - Perfect definition, sharpness and contrast.

Reply


setentpet October 4 2009, 05:43:15 UTC
Least Favorite Icons
#4 - I like the idea behind the icon but unfortunately the texture is just too overpowering and distracting from Hermoine.
#13 - The crop is nice but the test is faded in spots, making it hard to read.

Favorite Icon
#7 - Great use of negative space.
#6 - Could use a little more brightning but the crop is fantastic.

Reply


justmyb0nes October 4 2009, 06:17:57 UTC
Least Favorite Icons
05 - The crop doesn't fit the cap. I am sorry to say that but we can barely see what's happening on the icon. We can't see details of the caps because of the overuse of light.
03 - The quality of the pic was lost due to the overuse of brightness and it doesn't fit a close crop. The icon is a bit oversharpened too.

Favorite Icon
06 - The crop fits perfectly the cap and the black and white is vey well balanced
01 - The text placement fits the texture and the crop used. Very artistic use of clouds and light which increase the emotion of the icon and make us focus on the characters.

Reply


immortalje October 4 2009, 10:01:00 UTC
Least Favorite Icons
#5 - The crop makes it hard to see what is depicted.
#2 - The icon lacks contrast and seems a bit dark as a result. Also, the crop seems a bit awkward with the way the classes blend into the background on the left side making it look as if they were cut of and replaced with a black border on the side

Favorite Icon
#7 - Nice crop
#15 - Nice crop and texture use.

It's so hard to pick Least Favourite icons this time... and I hope my reason for #2 is understandable the way I tried to explain things.

Reply


egotists October 4 2009, 16:29:31 UTC
Least Favorite Icons
#14 - Cuts off too much of his face and is fairly flat in contrast.
#9 - The texture makes the icon look ragged almost. It's a bit over sharpened and quite a bit under contrasted.

Favorite Icon
#11 - Simple, pretty cut and nice use of texture.
#6 - A very alluring cut with a simple contrast that makes it stand out.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up