YT 2016 Tag Set Open

Sep 24, 2016 18:40

Here is the Yuletide 2016 tag set, in all of its glory.

For those who are curious:
Number of fandoms: 3077 and 12609 characters.
This compares to 3182 fandoms last year and 13329 characters last year.

Fandoms with 10+ nominations:
  • Galavant (11)
  • Imperial Radch Series - Ann Leckie (11)
  • The Goblin Emperor - Katherine Addison (12)
  • Penny Dreadful (TV) ( ( Read more... )

nom review, tag set review

Leave a comment

Comments 332

melody_jade September 24 2016, 18:40:47 UTC
I am not the nominator, but I believe some characters from Sunless Sea have wandered into Fallen London | Echo Bazaar.

The characters in question are:
The Brisk Campaigner
The Sigil-Ridden Navigator
The Tireless Mechanic

These characters are Sunless Sea specific, and AFAIK do not appear in Fallen London.

Reply

morbane September 24 2016, 20:47:57 UTC
Thank you! We'll see if we can pin them down to one.

Reply


15dozentimes September 24 2016, 18:42:02 UTC
Misspelling! Under fandom Drunk History RPF, the character "Mark Galgiardi (Drunk History RPF)", that last name should be Gagliardi

Reply

morbane September 24 2016, 20:51:44 UTC
Got it - thanks!

Reply


flamebyrd September 24 2016, 18:45:44 UTC
Both "X -エックス- | X/1999" and "Tokyo Babylon" contain the "Sumeragi Hokuto" tag. She does appear in both but one of them should probably have disambiguating text.

Reply

morbane September 24 2016, 20:52:08 UTC
Thanks! She was probably nominated in only one; we'll have to figure out which one that was.

(Edit: and checking spreadsheets, it looks like it was Tokyo Babylon.)

Reply


Dark Souls video games lesserstorm September 24 2016, 18:51:48 UTC
Something's a bit odd with the Dark souls video games - I don't know the canon so I don't know how helpful this is, but you have 2 fandoms called "Dark Souls (Video Games)" and "Dark Souls III" and they have two characters in common with no disambiguation. I'd suggest either combining if they are one canon or adding disambiguations to "Dark Souls (Video Games)" and to the characters "Lothric Younger Prince" and "Darkmoon Knightess"

Reply

Re: Dark Souls video games croik September 24 2016, 20:15:16 UTC
I'm one of the Dark Souls III nominators. Dark Souls III is a sequel to the original Dark Souls and they have a few characters in common, they take place a few centuries apart. In my experience most people use Dark Souls (Video Games) for the first game only and not as a franchise tag, but if thats' what it's meant to be, I'm okay with my noms being looped into it.

Either way Lothric Younger Prince only appears in Dark Souls III, if that makes a difference.

Reply

Re: Dark Souls video games morbane September 24 2016, 21:11:35 UTC
Thanks for adding information! We'll pin Lothric to Dark Souls III and I suspect Darkmoon Knightess should only be appearing in Dark Souls (Video Games).

Reply

Re: Dark Souls video games morbane September 24 2016, 21:10:59 UTC
Thanks for pointing that out! It looks like one character from each has wandered into the other. I don't think we'll combine them at this stage unless several participants would prefer that.

Reply


myr_soleil September 24 2016, 18:54:14 UTC
Hi! I nominated Presidential (Podcast) without characters. The podcast is a non-fiction series of US presidents' portraits. I was wondering why it was rejected?

The reason why I nominated the podcast and not, say, US Presidents RPF, is because on the podcast the host always asks what would it be like to go on a date with the subject of that week's episode. I wanted to request something where any/all president(s) (hence no characters) were suddenly going on blind dates and wondering what was going on. I feel that asking for US Presidents RPF and then springing that kind of request on a writer would be kind of mean!

Thanks for all your hard work and sorry to be creating more work for you this year with my wacky nomination ;)

Reply

morbane September 24 2016, 21:14:45 UTC
I see! Thank you - we were very puzzled by this nomination. We will add it to the list for discussion.

Reply

myr_soleil September 25 2016, 14:48:12 UTC
Thank you!

Reply

thenewradical September 24 2016, 23:31:39 UTC
omg I am so into this idea.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up