YT 2016 Tag Set Open

Sep 24, 2016 18:40

Here is the Yuletide 2016 tag set, in all of its glory.

For those who are curious:
Number of fandoms: 3077 and 12609 characters.
This compares to 3182 fandoms last year and 13329 characters last year.

Fandoms with 10+ nominations:
  • Galavant (11)
  • Imperial Radch Series - Ann Leckie (11)
  • The Goblin Emperor - Katherine Addison (12)
  • Penny Dreadful (TV) (12)
  • Dark Matter (TV) (14)
  • Critical Role (Web Series) (15)
  • Stranger Things (TV 2016) (16)
  • Killjoys (TV) (18)
  • Ghostbusters (2016) (19)


Corrections

Very helpful corrections

  • Mis-spelled characters
  • Characters that appear in the wrong fandom
  • Characters that are missing from a fandom, when you expected them to be there (i.e, you nominated them there
  • Characters who appear in multiple fandoms with exactly the same character tag (this is an indication the tag has wandered)
  • Mis-spelled fandoms
  • Fandoms that don’t match their characters
  • Fandoms that occur twice in the tag set under different names
  • Fandoms that don’t appear in a category they should appear in
  • Fandoms that are missing (i.e., you or a friend nominated them and you aren’t sure why they should be absent).

Please tell us about any of these problems. When commenting, please include the following information:
  • the current fandom tag
  • the current character tags
  • the problem you see and the changes you suggest.
The edit interface is particular. Careful description saves us a lot of work.

Less helpful corrections

  • Inconsistent disambiguation tags used for the characters in a fandom - while it’s nice to be tidy, if all the characters belong to a fandom, we’re happy enough
  • Telling us that your fandom appears in two or more categories. If your fandom appears in the wrong category, please check whether or not it also appears in the right one. If it does, the tag set is functioning as it should
  • Fixing capitalisation and diacritics on tags
  • .

Challenges

We try to consider all fandoms carefully, but we may have rejected or accepted a fandom in error.

If you believe your fandom has been treated incorrectly:
  • Please give the name of your fandom and the characters that were nominated.
  • Please give a clear and concise explanation of why you believe it should have been approved.
  • Please check if someone else has raised the same issue, on Dreamwidth and Livejournal, and if possible, add your thoughts to the same thread.

If the fandom was over on numbers, and there was no evidence post, we will not reconsider the fandom.

If the fandom was closely related to a fandom that is over on numbers, and there was no evidence post, we will not reconsider the fandom.

If the fandom was a fanwork of a large fandom, and there was no evidence post, we will not reconsider the fandom.

If you simply want to ask why a decision was made, you are welcome to do so, but an explanation (even one you disagree with) does not mean the case is re-opened.

Challenges must be submitted before 9pm UTC 30 September to be considered (What time is that for me?). We ask you to submit corrections before this as well, to ensure that sign-ups can open on time.

nom review, tag set review

Previous post Next post
Up