Noms Queries Post 1

Sep 18, 2016 14:55

We're around 29 hours time into tagmodding, and have sorted 2,202 nominations.

There are currently 2757 fandom nominations remaining, and 1109 fandoms and 5126 characters approved!

We have the following questions:

  • The Broken Earth Trilogy - N. K. Jemisin
    • character “Damaya | Essun | Syenite” - please confirm if you want all variants, or just ( Read more... )

nom review

Leave a comment

Comments 37

abluegirl September 18 2016, 14:15:33 UTC
Death Proof (2007), Grindhouse (2007) - I nominated one of these, and yes, it is OK to combine them.

Reply

jenn_calaelen September 18 2016, 14:18:19 UTC
Thank you for the quick reply!

Reply


tarlanx September 18 2016, 14:29:09 UTC
Dark Matter - Episode 2.08: Stuff to Steal, People to Kill - the crew of Raza end up in an alternate (mirror) universe where the Raza crew are more mercenary. So the answer is YES, Mirror Marcus Boone is a valid character, separate from Marcus Boone.

Reply

jenn_calaelen September 18 2016, 14:36:00 UTC
Thank you for the info! :)

Reply


tigerbright September 18 2016, 14:34:16 UTC
I didn't nominate Broken Earth, but I personally would combine them all, even though it makes the character name a spoiler.

Reply

jenn_calaelen September 18 2016, 14:40:18 UTC
Thank you for info. We know it would be a spoiler, but sadly there are cases where having a good and clear tagset means there have to be spoilers!

Reply

elanya September 18 2016, 18:52:11 UTC
It was my nom, an I meant to keep them all combined, yes.

I didn't nominate Nessun though (and don't have the book to double check), so I can't speak for that one!

Reply

jenn_calaelen September 18 2016, 18:57:03 UTC
Thanks for commenting! There were several noms for the character, so we'll consider all replies from nommers in trying to sort it out.

Reply


tryfanstone September 18 2016, 14:54:53 UTC
China Court - Rumer Godden, character Mrs Quin - could the nominator clarify which Mrs Quin is intended?

Nominator. Although there are technically many Mrs Quins in China Court, the Mrs Quin known as a child as Ripsie is the only one referred in the text as Mrs Quin. The other Mrs Quins are always identified as either first name only or nickname only. If you'd like to differentiate for this character, 'Ripsie' (no surname) would be fine, or 'Old Mrs Quin', but please not Mrs Ripsie Quin. China Court plays with timelines, and differentiates this character by naming her either Ripsie or Mrs Quin, but never both together.

Hope this helps.

Reply

liviapenn September 18 2016, 14:56:05 UTC

Not familiar with this fandom, but perhaps "Ripsie | Mrs Quin" would work, to indicate that this character goes by both names?

Reply

tryfanstone September 18 2016, 15:01:12 UTC
Perfect - that works. Thank you! (Best of luck this year!)

Reply

liviapenn September 18 2016, 15:09:55 UTC

Thanks, to you too! :)

Reply


likeaduck September 18 2016, 15:01:39 UTC
The Broken Earth Trilogy - N. K. Jemisin
character “Damaya | Essun | Syenite” - please confirm if you want all variants, or just Essun, or Damaya and Essun separately?
-i nominated Damaya separately, not sure if someone else nominated the others, I was aiming for Damaya separately, if that's allowed, but realise it might need to be combined, & that's fine
character “Nassun” - did you mean Nessun?
-nope, "Nassun" is the correct spelling

Reply

jenn_calaelen September 18 2016, 15:04:58 UTC
Thank you for the info. We've had several nominations for The Broken Earth Trilogy - N. K. Jemisin with various combination and separate tags for the character, so we'll see what other responses we get from them as well!

Reply


Leave a comment

Up