Noms Queries Post 1

Sep 18, 2016 14:55

We're around 29 hours time into tagmodding, and have sorted 2,202 nominations.

There are currently 2757 fandom nominations remaining, and 1109 fandoms and 5126 characters approved!

We have the following questions:

  • The Broken Earth Trilogy - N. K. Jemisin
    • character “Damaya | Essun | Syenite” - please confirm if you want all variants, or just Essun, or Damaya and Essun separately?
    • character “Nassun” - did you mean Nessun?
  • Genghis Khan - Miike Snow (Music Video) - We have received nominations for the following characters:
    • Fake Bond Villain
    • Fake Bond Villainess
    • Fake James Bond
    • Gold Nose Villain (Genghis Khan - Miike Snow)
    • Henchman (Genghis Khan - Miike Snow)
    • Henchmen (Genghis Khan - Miike Snow)
    • Minion (Genghis Khan - Miike Snow)
    • Secret Agent (Genghis Khan - Miike Snow)
    • Villain (Genghis Khan - Mike Snow)
    • Wife (Genghis Khan - Miike Snow)
    • Although some of these characters make sense, there is a huge variety of overlap. Would the nominators please comment on which characters they meant for their various labels?
  • Death Proof (2007), Grindhouse (2007) - We received some separate and some combined nominations for these films. We intend to combine them unless participants advance compelling arguments for their remaining separate.
  • Austin & Murry-O'Keefe Families - Madeleine L'Engle, characters - Adam Eddington, Emily Davidson, Josiah Davidson, Polly O'Keefe, Suzy Austin, Vicky Austin, Zachary Gray and Kairos (O'Keefe) Series - Madeleine L'Engle, characters - Calvin O'Keefe, Dennys Murry, Meg Murry | Meg O'Keefe, Proginoskes, Sandy Murry, Yalith (Many Waters) -- There are overlapping nominations. We intend to combine them, unless participants advance compelling arguments for their remaining separate.
  • Both Mabinogion and Welsh Mythology are nominated. Is the Welsh Mythology nominator OK with us folding Gwynn ap Nudd into Mabinogion?
  • Dark Matter (TV), character - Mirror Marcus Boone - can anyone confirm that this is a valid character, separate from Marcus Boone?
  • Department S & Jason King, characters Annabelle Hurst, Jason King, Sir Curtis Seretse, Stewart Sullivan - all of these are characters from Department S, is the nominator okay with it going through as that series?
  • Detention (2011), character Ione/Sloan - could the nominator confirm whether they mean Riley's contemporary friend or the time-traveller who swapped lives with her mother
  • China Court - Rumer Godden, character Mrs Quin - could the nominator clarify which Mrs Quin is intended?
  • The Trump Files - Owen Ellickson (@onlxn), TRUMP LEAKS - @onlxn - can anyone confirm that these are intended to be the same fandom?
  • Gallifrey, character Romana, K9 - There were also noms for specific Romanas - could the nominator confirm which Romana they wanted? Also which K9 they intended?

We need clarification from the person (or people) who nominated the following fandoms. Please specify a single version of the canon and provide a link to your nominations page so we can confirm the nomination. If these aren't answered, the fandoms will be rejected:
  • The Worst Journey in the World - All Media Types, characters - Apsley Cherry-Garrard, Henry Robertson "Birdie" Bowers, Lawrence Oates
  • No. 6 - All Media Types, characters - Inukashi (No. 6), Nezumi (No. 6), Rikiga (No. 6), Shion (No. 6)
  • Firestarter - All Media Types, characters - Andy McGee, Charlie McGee
  • The Midnight Meat Train, characters - Jurgis Thompkins, Lynn Hadley, Otto (The Midnight Meat Train), Susan Hoff
  • Mario Kart - Fandom, character Waluigi (Nintendo)


This post is now closed. Please put new comments on the next query post.

nom review

Previous post Next post
Up