Requesting Clarifications

Sep 28, 2012 17:23

1. Characters seeking homes! If you nominated one of the following characters, we need to know what fandom it belongs to.

  • Cassius
  • Clementine
  • Richard Speight Jr.
  • June
  • Holger

    2. Collective nominations of fandoms that need to be narrower:

  • Kamen Riders series -- we can do individual series, but not the overall universe. If you nominated this and ( Read more... )
  • yuletide 2012, corrections, nominations

    Leave a comment

    Comments 44

    chimerari September 28 2012, 23:51:21 UTC
    2. tinker tailor soldier spy
    *raises hand guitily* it was me who put in TTSS (all media types), I'll go change it now. btw just wondering where could I find the 'optional details' part?

    Reply

    elynross September 28 2012, 23:57:18 UTC
    Hey, no guilt! It wasn't an unreasonable thing to do.

    You can't actually change it now, as it got accepted already; we're just trying to clean up duplications. *g* If you let me know what you'd like it changed to (the older TV miniseries? The book?), if you want to specify, I can do that. But the optional details are what you put in your requests when you sign up, so that's not something you can do now.

    Reply

    chimerari September 29 2012, 00:00:16 UTC
    phew, thanks, thought I left out an optional detials part when I filled in the form (it's been known to happen)
    I guess change it to the movie will be the best option really, since that's what most people are familiar with. Thanks a bunch for your help

    Reply

    elynross September 29 2012, 00:12:47 UTC
    Is that the new movie? If so, I'll just make sure all the characters from your nomination are available!

    Reply


    kitrazzle September 29 2012, 05:14:25 UTC
    RE: Steam Powered Giraffe

    Feel free to eliminate The Humans option.

    Reply

    lacunarity September 29 2012, 13:38:53 UTC
    Feel free to eliminate The Humans option.

    That sounds mighty ominous for a cheery band about robots.

    Reply

    kitrazzle September 29 2012, 20:37:43 UTC
    At least I didn't say exterminate! ;)

    Reply

    elynross September 30 2012, 21:37:32 UTC
    If you're sure! I can definitely change it to a specific name.

    Reply


    (The comment has been removed)

    belina September 29 2012, 15:45:45 UTC
    I think you'll have to settle for something specific from her work. At the moment you've got two fandoms there, Antique Bakery and Ooku.

    Antique Bakery I've seen nominated before. After a quick search it came up with only 26 stories on AO3, so at least regarding the fics on AO3 it is eligible. Maybe check the 'when is a fandom eligible' guide for other indicators (ff.net, other archives?).
    I haven't found anything for Ooku, looks like it would be new to the AO3 tag list.

    If you've got two nominations still open, take them both. Otherwise you might have to choose one of them and run with that.

    On the characters I can't really help as I always am very specific with my characters. ^^; I know there was a discussion once how to handle characters if it really doesn't matter to you and you're fine with 'Any'. I hope someone else can help you on that. *crosses fingers*

    Reply

    geri_chan September 30 2012, 02:10:41 UTC
    I remembered seeing a Yuletide treat for Ooku in the past, so I did some digging and found it in the Yuletide Madness 2010 collection. It's listed as Ooku: The Inner Chambers or Ōoku. Hope that helps!

    Reply

    belina September 30 2012, 08:10:00 UTC
    I see!

    Just rechecked and it IS indeed Ōoku and not just Ooku. But I guess with 3 stories (2 over 1000 words) it would still be eligible. ;)

    Now I just wonder about the 'ōo' combo and want to see it written in Japanese... ^^;

    Reply


    bettef September 30 2012, 17:51:37 UTC
    Cassius might have been mine for Julius Caesar - William Shakespeare.

    Reply

    elynross September 30 2012, 21:42:04 UTC
    Yay, that's it, I'll put him in his place! *g*

    Reply


    bettef September 30 2012, 17:54:19 UTC
    I also nominated Brutus in that fandom, without the (Julius Caesar - Shakespeare) tag after it. So if that's a question too, Brutus and Cassius are probably both mine :)

    Reply

    elynross September 30 2012, 21:56:30 UTC
    No, Brutus went through fine. It's an arcane process, I'm never quite sure how characters become "unassociated" from their approved fandoms. *g*

    Reply


    Leave a comment

    Up