Vetting period ended.

[hhertzof]

We've ended the call for corrections and locked the last two posts. We will carefully consider the last few challenges and make the last few fixes. Sign-ups will open at some point this afternoon or early evening, EDT.

We thank you for all the time you spent pouring over the tag set and all the fixes you've brought to our attention.

Comments

[carbonel]

"Instrumentality of Man" should be "Instrumentality of Mankind."

[hhertzof]

Thanks, fixing.

[carbonel]

What happened to the Chapel Hollow books by Nina Kiriki Hoffman? I nominated them (ETA: at least, I thought I did), and they should certainly qualify. But they're not there under Books and Literature, which is where they fit.

[morbane]

If you're not sure if you nominated them, perhaps you can check by going to the tag set (http://archiveofourown.org/tag_sets/221/) and clicking "My Nominations"? (I know the mods are closing the tag set for short periods to help them fix things, but it might pay to check.)

[jenn_calaelen]

It looks like it has gone missing - sorry. Morbane pointed you at where to check if you had nommed it. If you have please tell us the characters and we'll add it.

[carbonel]

Er, um. I misremembered. For some reason I thought I had five nominations, and that was the fifth. But there are only four.

My apologies.

[carbonel]

There's a listing for "Tir Tanagiri -- Jo Walton." I think this should be subsumed into "The King's Name -- Jo Walton." Tir Tanagiri is a location in the books.

And the entire series is more properly called "The King's Peace" than "The King's Name." It's a two-book duology, with "The King Peace" being the first one.

[jenn_calaelen]

Thank you for pointing this out. They will be merged.

[gwyn_r]

I'm a little frustrated at the locking of the post, making it impossible to reply to your comment that essentially missed the entire point of my "challenge" about commercial fandoms. I was pointing out that there are MULTIPLE tag sets of variants on the names of a number of TV commercials fandoms -- and all of them are exactly the same commercials/characters. And that the tag sets for almost all of them ALREADY EXISTED as separate fandoms. And the reason they were separate fandoms was because when they are all lumped together, we are forced to offer two characters, which we may not be able to do, so no one offers those fandoms. This was something elyn specifically addressed last year because of problems in the previous year. You are completely brushing off the fact that this worked fine last year, and that these tag sets already exist, and the numerous variants being there is just...after all the complaining about tag bloat, why completely ignore this and brush someone off?

[morbane]

This is kind of confusing (well, duh, I imagine you might you say...). What do you think it ought to look like right now?

[gwyn_r]

It IS confusing, which was why I kept trying to comment on it and stave off issues. I guess it's probably irrelevant if signups are open. But let me try to explain

[dhampyresa]

Since carbonel is bringing up issues and having them corrected and you appear to have no problem correcting disappearing nominations, I would like to ask again that Gwen Stacy be added as a character to the Ultimate Spider-Man fandom. Please and thank you.

[jenn_calaelen]

She's been added to the tag set and will be associated with the fandom before signups.

[tamarind_rogue]

Thank you so much for listening to the fans. :) We're glad to have her.

[innerbrat]

Thank you for doing this.