Comments | yamisakura38: o.O Soul or Soulless!!??

yamisakura38

o.O Soul or Soulless!!??

Jan 10, 2008 20:48

J-san [SocialGenius1] has been urging me to post my thought in his thread. While I was thinking about it... all these Soul and Soulless things... At first, I had my solid thinking.. then when Chapter 178 came out... my mind go completely bizzare. And then with some slight straighten-up by others in TF, I thought I understood about the Soul issue ( Read more... )

trc, soul, theory, syaoran, sakura, mind explode

Comments 6

cutesherry January 11 2008, 07:09:42 UTC

First, I think we should ponder about the difference between 'clone' and 'replica' : because, from the translation, this is the difference in naming that FWR used : the real Syaoran was cloned while princess Sakura was replicated ( ... )

yamisakura38 January 11 2008, 19:07:28 UTC

Actually, when I read your "clone" and "replica" differences, I thought CLAMP use different words to represent it as well. However, I just checked on Ch. 119 raw scan [su-chan LJ picture gallaries has the HQ raw scan for vol 16-21 ^.^]. I recognized that FWR use the same word to describe ClSyaoran as he is decribing C|Sakura. And thus, there's no differences in CLAMP's definition between the word "clone" and "replica"... just neither-sama "made" a different between those 2. Actually reading the "chinese translation" of it, they use the word "clone" as well. I don't believe there's a cloning different between C|Sakura and C|Syaoran ( ... )

cutesherry January 11 2008, 09:19:11 UTC

Another subject so another post :)
About the payment to Yuuko from volume01, Seishiro (in Tsubasa forum) stated a *very* optimistic view of it, saying that since it's the replicated soul who paid, then the 'real' Sakura still remembers Syaoran o.O
I do not agree with this.
Yuuko said herself that this price is far more complicated then it looked...
And do you remember vol16, when the real Syaoran went to Yuuko's shop?
She said that one of his three prices was his 'relationship', but it's the clone who *supposedly* 'paid' with it, not him.
From this, can't we logically conclude it's the same with the real Sakura too...?

socialgenius1 January 11 2008, 09:58:05 UTC

Hey, so you are twisting yourself into knots over the soul issue. XD ( ... )

socialgenius1 January 11 2008, 09:59:41 UTC

And yes, I'm encouraging you to post all this on Cloney's soul. Btw, is it in our capability to change the thread title?

yamisakura38 January 11 2008, 19:32:03 UTC

HAHA~~ I should ^.~ to get the "discussion" in there, ne? instead of in my LJ ^^;; And sorry, you need to "copy/paste" your response to TF and add in more in there.