Trek ficlet, warnings discussion

Jun 25, 2009 12:17

Fandom is having quite the debate over warnings. Though I am definitely on the fringes of this, it's been a real eye-opener for me in a lot of ways; I'd generally thought of myself as anti-warning, but reading the posts and discussions has made me realize that I was coming at this from a very limited perspective. Basically, I don't tend to write ( Read more... )

warnings, st:aos, ficlets

Leave a comment

Comments 33

cmdr_zoom June 25 2009, 16:25:43 UTC
*aws at I-Chaya, and again at Spock discovering a new world*

Reply

yahtzee63 June 25 2009, 17:08:46 UTC
Glad you like!

Reply


slow_waking June 25 2009, 16:40:47 UTC
" (An appreciation of aesthetic qualities is not illogical.)"

Well yes, the entire little ficlet was lovely -- I love the idea of Spock coming to Earth with nothing but a duffel bag with some clothes ( especially because it fits so well with him -- an emotional attachment to certain objects isn't very Vulcan now, is it? ). But this one line was worth a grin and a scribble onto an index card ( which is where all my one-liners from fics end up ).

And the idea that when you're new in a place, it doesn't really matter where you're heading. I do a lot of traveling, and it struck me as how true that can actually be.

Reply

yahtzee63 June 25 2009, 17:10:31 UTC
Thanks for the prompt, and so glad you enjoyed the results!

Reply


suehypno June 25 2009, 17:07:25 UTC
Here's my take on warnings.

I was sent a SW story a while ago to read. I was warned that it had explicit sex and some violence in it. That's par for the course if it's a good Han/Leia action story, right? Heck, I'm HOPING for some smutty sex! Well, I'm getting into it (it's written well) and suddenly it's a violent alien raping Leia story, in all the gorely details. WTF?? I was traumitized WITH her. I did NOT appreciate this. I explained to the author that she needed to adjust her warnings because they weren't remotely accurate.

See what I mean?

Reply

yahtzee63 June 25 2009, 17:11:15 UTC
Agreed, and also, ew.

Reply


mrstater June 25 2009, 17:37:51 UTC
What a lovely drabble. It's neat to see Spock a little out of his element, and yet taking everything in stride.

Reply

yahtzee63 June 25 2009, 18:06:39 UTC
Thanks muchly!

Reply


kassrachel June 25 2009, 18:08:59 UTC
Lovely Spock piece, as always.

Reply

yahtzee63 June 25 2009, 18:30:44 UTC
Glad you like!

Reply


Leave a comment

Up