SO MANY QUESTIONS

Oct 08, 2009 04:47

Can somebody please explain to me about what is going on? I am not sure I understand. Some people want to keep a list of who we are? Why? Is that bad?

nia teppelin

Leave a comment

Comments 53

teloschain October 8 2009, 08:52:06 UTC
They think we're dangerous and want to make themselves feel better. Whether "better" means "safer" or "superior" is anybody's guess, but...

It pretty much boils down to fear, I think. And if they keep a list of us, some think it would make things easier for those who want to hunt us down.

Reply

fuckyeahmaths October 8 2009, 08:56:31 UTC
But are we not dangerous? I should think it a little thing to give our names, and besides, if they try to hunt any of us down we shall stop them.

Reply

teloschain October 8 2009, 09:01:05 UTC
Not all of us are. I know of at least a few students, myself included, whose only known power is healing, flight, or something along those lines. We're not directly dangerous, at least.

Many of us can't defend ourselves, at least not yet, and not all of us can be together all of the time - but I think I get what you're saying. It'll be good if we stick together.

Reply

fuckyeahmaths October 8 2009, 09:10:19 UTC
If your power is healing, should you not be on a list so that you may help people? I thought many people could heal, though they work very hard to learn it, and must register also.

Reply


fuckyeahmaths October 8 2009, 08:53:12 UTC
They wish to keep a list of who we are, so that if we damage something that is not ours or hurt somebody, we might be held accountable. I think it is a fine idea.

Reply

cloudpower October 8 2009, 09:00:28 UTC
Oh. But regular people hurt other people too, do we also keep a list of them? My father hurt a lot of people he didn't like and I don't think anybody keeps a list of him.

Reply

fuckyeahmaths October 8 2009, 09:13:10 UTC
Laurence had to write a great deal when we first arrived, for the census, but I do not think that is the same. You are all registered as humans whilst I am not allowed.

Reply

cloudpower October 8 2009, 09:17:04 UTC
I didn't know that, my father has not taught me very much about... things. I'm glad I'm here so I can learn!

I'm sorry, why don't they let you do the um... "census"?

Reply


hugling October 8 2009, 10:49:57 UTC
It kinda is, because all the people who want to keep a list are the kind of people who think mutants shouldn't be allowed to get jobs or live in the same neighborhoods as regular people.

Reply

cloudpower October 8 2009, 11:06:10 UTC
But that's awful! Why would people think that?

Reply


stepsonflowers October 8 2009, 11:07:02 UTC
It's bad because it criminalizes us and puts us and everyone we know in danger just because we were lucky enough to be born with an X-Gene.

Reply

cloudpower October 8 2009, 11:10:51 UTC
It is a list of criminals?

Reply

stepsonflowers October 8 2009, 11:18:55 UTC
The idea is to keep a list of mutants in case our powers ever go out of whack or we use them and people get hurt in the process, so we'd be held accountable. Sounds all nice in theory, right?

Thing is, you don't register people based on what's in their double helix. You register criminals-- sex offenders, murderers and the like. Whether they know it or not, asking us to register is putting us on their level. It tells people we're a continued threat so long as we exist. That we're something to be hated and feared when most of us just want to get on with our lives.

Reply

cloudpower October 8 2009, 11:30:31 UTC
But Temeraire said it could also be a list so that we can help people... that is good, right?

Reply


crayolamutant October 8 2009, 13:17:26 UTC
I think people shouldn't have to know you're a mutant if you never use your power.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up