Comments | whatpipeswhy: Writer's Block: The name game

whatpipeswhy

Writer's Block: The name game

Jan 31, 2011 20:29

Comments 5

gargargarrick February 1 2011, 01:42:53 UTC

The crazy thing is that it was originally a love song. There was one version for dudes to sing about ladies (Eily Dear), and one version for ladies to sing about dudes (Danny Boy). Only the latter is widely performed nowadays, and we’ve pretty much forgotten how incredibly gay it is for a male singer to use those lyrics…

whatpipeswhy February 1 2011, 23:10:19 UTC

Why have people forgotten it's a love song, and that there's a girl version?

gargargarrick February 6 2011, 09:42:03 UTC

Eh, this happens all the time with traditional music. House of the Rising Sun was originally a song about a lady falling for a good-for-nothing and, ultimately, becoming a prostitute (warning other women not to make the same mistake). Someone made a Perspective Flip about the aforementioned good-for-nothing and it just stuck.

whatpipeswhy February 10 2011, 03:24:49 UTC

Honestly, the original sounds more interesting.

Thread 5