Review of Philip Roth's Plot Against America

Dec 21, 2007 03:22



A Pictorial Review of
The Plot Against America

by Philip Roth
by Troy Swain, in the style of Charles Schulz

Page 1, 2, 3

Read more... )

books, book reviews, my comics, comics

Leave a comment

Comments 19

(The comment has been removed)

uberdionysus December 21 2007, 17:48:20 UTC
Thank you!

Reply


(The comment has been removed)

uberdionysus December 21 2007, 17:49:06 UTC
What would have been awesome?

And thanks!

Reply

(The comment has been removed)

uberdionysus December 21 2007, 19:05:09 UTC
Right now I wish I was P.Danny or shamroq. I KNOW there's a great joke in there somewhere, but I just can't tease it out.

Reply


? vengeance_is_me December 21 2007, 13:09:49 UTC
have you ever thought about creating an on-going book review comic for a newspaper? like, you read a popular book over however many weeks and then draw a review comic of it? i think that would be a fun idea. and you're more than skilled enough to do it.

the cool thing about it is, even if you don't read the entire book in a week, just a few panels like this are just enough to get people interested, because obviously you don't want to spoil the book for them by revealing everything; just a nice overview. which i think (reading and drawing of a simple 4-8 panel comic) could be done in a week. hell, if i had the time, i'd do it. but i don't think they'd appreciate a t-rex with tank tread legs and a cannon sticking out of his chest a good book review.

Reply

uberdionysus December 21 2007, 17:50:30 UTC
Yeah, I'd like that. And I think I'd need more than 4-8 panels - but if someone gave me the same amount of space they give a normal book review, I'd be able to do it.

This job is over in Jan., so after that I'm going to pursue it.

Reply

then December 21 2007, 19:29:15 UTC
uberdionysus December 21 2007, 20:06:31 UTC
That's not a review, that's an illustration. Cool idea, tho'.

Reply


then December 21 2007, 16:27:19 UTC
uberdionysus December 21 2007, 17:51:54 UTC
Is that a song?

Reply

flying_squid December 21 2007, 18:23:09 UTC
It's the "Peanuts" theme that's played all the time in the TV specials. The actual title is "Linus and Lucy."

Reply

uberdionysus December 21 2007, 19:05:32 UTC
I didn't know that! Cool.

Reply


flying_squid December 21 2007, 17:19:11 UTC
I like how this reminds more of the older Peanuts strips rather than the "classic" ones we're all familiar with, that are still being printed in newspapers.

Reply

uberdionysus December 21 2007, 17:51:39 UTC
I really like the early stuff. The 50s and 60s stuff is so sad and poignant and funny. I think he lost momentum in the 80s, and after that, he just wasn't as good.

Reply

flying_squid December 21 2007, 18:28:07 UTC
To be fair on Schulz' part, he was aging and such. There's only so much you can put into a work for that long, on top of getting old, etc.

That said, you're definitely right about the 80s being signs that he was slowing down. I think Art Spiegelman points out the same thing in this book (the first entry is Spiegelman on the death of Schultz).

Reply

rival December 21 2007, 20:20:53 UTC
Yeah, I was about to say. You even nailed the oval (vs. round) heads.

Great stuff, Troy.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up