r5c10 - voting

[endearest]

Voting Rules;
---> Voting will stay up until Sunday evening. You do not need to be a participant to vote. Voting is not required but much appreciated. If you are a entrant: you are no longer required to vote. You may if you choose but it's understandable if you choose not to.---> Vote for the icon you think is of the worst quality. Please vote

Comments

[mayfrayn]

Voting Off:
WORST (-1 points): #03 - the composition is too plain and the figures seem placed in the icon without a purpose. The colouring is nice though

Favorites:
FAVORITE (+1 points): #04 - wonderful composition and good use of b/w

[cinnamonstreet]

Voting Off:
WORST (-1 points): #02 poor text that doesn't fit with the icon

Favorites:
FAVORITE (+1 points): #04

[endearest]

sorry could you check your number for worst? (reason doesn't match icon :) )

(and thanks for voting in all challenges <3 )

[cinnamonstreet]

I'm sorry I wrote wrong.. #03 of course :P

You're welcome ;)

[lady_kingsley]

Voting Off:
WORST (-1 points): #03 - Alice and Jasper could be more sharpen and more colorful, and I don't like this texture behind them

Favorites:
FAVORITE (+1 points): #04 - Perfect crops, like from movie shoots, perfect contrast and presentation

[tiah15]

Voting Off:
WORST (-1 points): #01 - While the Edward/Bella blend is done well both look very sharp (mostly their eyes). The moon texture doesn't fit into the icon very well but makes it look too busy instead.

Favorites:
FAVORITE (+1 points): #04

[lauralovesnaley]

Voting Off:
WORST (-1 points): #01 - The textures used overcrowd the icon and Bella and Edward need more saturation, especially in their faces.

Favorites:
FAVORITE (+1 points): #04 - Unique interpretation and nice coloring.