r5c10 - voting

[endearest]

Voting Rules;
---> Voting will stay up until Sunday evening. You do not need to be a participant to vote. Voting is not required but much appreciated. If you are a entrant: you are no longer required to vote. You may if you choose but it's understandable if you choose not to.---> Vote for the icon you think is of the worst quality. Please vote

Comments

[nodazzle]

Voting Off:
WORST (-1 points): #01 - I think the blending is done quite well and the colouring isn't bad but the image is very pixelated - which is enhanced because of the scratchy textures used.

Favorites:
FAVORITE (+1 points): #04 - I really like the composition here and the black and white is contrasted well.

[setentpet]

Voting Off:
WORST (-1 points): #01 - The background chosen doesn't really flow well with the icon and Edward and Bella are a little blurry, especially in the face.

Favorites:
FAVORITE (+1 points): #04 - The icon is amazing. The blending is well done and the contrast is beautiful.

[sidhex3]

Voting Off:
WORST (-1 points): #01 - having the texture on top of the subjects, rather than behind them is quite disorienting and looks very odd.

Favorites:
FAVORITE (+1 points): #04

[beckyhelene]

Voting Off:
WORST (-1 points): #01 - Icon looks oversharpened. The blending of the two images doesn't look as seamless as it could.

Favorites:
FAVORITE (+1 points): #03 - The blending is very good, very seamless and not forced, as if this was actually what the original picture looked like. The text is a nice little touch to the icon as a whole.

[endearest]

VOTING CLOSED