Voting Rules;
---> Voting will stay up until Sunday evening. You do not need to be a participant to vote. Voting is not required but much appreciated. If you are a entrant: you are no longer required to vote. You may if you choose but it's understandable if you choose not to.
---> Vote for the icon you think is of the worst quality. Please vote based on the quality of the icons, not on your personal preference. A great comment on voting can be found here:
http://community.livejournal.com/picknchooselims/6010.html--->Use the form below to comment to this post with the numbers of what you think is the worst icon and your ONE favorite icon as well. Please give an explanation for why those icons were your least favorites (again, based on quality) and also why the other was your favorites (if you choose to). Explanations are required for least favourite but only encouraged for favourite. For a more detailed explanation of how voting points work, see the
rules post.Please take the time to consider a few things when voting:
---> Aim for votes to be 1 - 2 complete sentences
---> If you can expand, do!
---> WHY & WHERE - why is it a bad thing, where is it happening?
---> If you're feeling helpful you can also offer a HOW it could be improved.
i.e. If the icon is too dark, explain why that is a negative thing (subject blends into the background, loss of definition etc). Oversharpened? Tell me where!
--->All comments are screened.
--->Use the form to vote.
--->You may not vote for yourself.
---> We will be voting off ONE participant this week.
---> There will be ONE People's choice
Voting Form;
---> Simply replace the #00's with the numbers of the icons you are voting for.
Voting Off:
WORST (-1 points): #00 - Reasons.
Favorites:
FAVORITE (+1 points): #00 - Reasons (optional but encouraged).
Challenge Nine Entries;
1
2
3
4
5
Be civil in your voting and follow the guidelines, if I find any comments insufficent or rude I will ask you to change them. Voting will be unscreened after winners are announced.
got a minute?
gglims, R1C8: 5 entries - Vote
HERExoxolims, R1C5: 7 entries - Vote
HEREstarlight_lims, R1C5: 6 entries - Vote
HERE