Brigit's Flame Week 2 Entry: Nine Lives

Jul 18, 2010 15:32

            I’ve always believed in true love.  I’ve just never found it.  Oh, sometimes I thought I had.  But then it never lasted, so how true was it, then?  I’ve been heartbroken several times; I know I’ve caused heartbreak myself.  It’s out there, though, I can sense it, feel the promise of its possibilities.  I think, for me, the purpose of ( Read more... )

brigit's flame

Leave a comment

Comments 8

vyvyan_wilde July 20 2010, 20:53:41 UTC
This felt so genuine and real, as if I was sitting on this woman's couch as she told me the story of her life. Great work, and good luck this week.

Reply

triplescorpio July 20 2010, 21:15:49 UTC
Oh, thanks so much. Your comment means a lot. Good luck to you too.

Reply


lolafalola July 21 2010, 15:45:09 UTC
This felt honest and open.

Here's hoping for the last!

Reply


Editor! attentionhoard July 22 2010, 02:45:15 UTC
Hello! I'm thrilled to be reading your writing again after my long hiatus! I trust you know my style, so I'm just going to leap right into it!

Here we go....

-----------

1. casement window is a fantastic, simple choice. Strong, clean image for us with a word that isn't used enough! Nice work!

2. Again, I applaud your simple, evocative sentiments. "I discovered that orgasms were delicious and I had them easily and often. ". Beautiful.

3. Minor typo: from Rober, = from Robert.

4. There's something so frighteningly and beautifully human about this final sentiment in the John "section" of the piece and I'd like to compliment the decision to finalize that "section" with: " But the sex was so very good . . .". Very interesting, visceral ( ... )

Reply

Re: Editor! triplescorpio July 22 2010, 02:53:29 UTC
I'm glad you're back, too. Actually, I had taken a break myself and this is the first contest I've participated in in quite a while. I so much appreciate you comments, they really mean a lot to me, especially coming from you. This piece does come from a place deep inside me, and I'm glad you found it so moving and beautiful. Thank you again, so much.

Reply


Comments from an editor fawatson August 7 2010, 14:47:17 UTC
You drew me again as an editor. I will add my comments here as you were OK with having them on the story itself last time. Hopefully they will go through this time (doing this using Airport WiFI and having some trouble with it!). Since the comments are too long for one post I'll let you have general ones here and poist a second comments with the suggestions about specific points.

GeneralAlthough the title is “Annie’s Story”, this isn’t really a story but the reminiscence of an emotionally insecure and shallow woman. You chose to write in the first person and as a narrative. This was a very effective voice to use (well done), so the image of the protagonist’s character comes through clearly, and that is a real strength of your work. However, I suggest you take another look at the structure of the piece as a whole. It meanders through various accounts of Annie’s relationships with men in a somewhat aimless way. True, this reflects her aimless life, but I cannot help thinking a little more structure would serve you better. As it ( ... )

Reply

Re: Comments from an editor fawatson August 7 2010, 14:48:20 UTC
Specific
All the comments below are about quite minor points, many of them the kind of typo (etc) which is addressed by careful proofreading and editing (which is always difficult to achieve when writing o a strict deadline as you do for the BF competition). In all cases I have quoted what you wrote first in italics and immediately followed with my suggestion.

But then it never lasted, so how true was it, then?
But then it never lasted, so how true was it? (reducing repetition)

And I was shy, feeling so very awkward
And I was shy, felt so very awkward (verb tense)

ashiness
Try: ‘ash’ (or just remove the word entirely)

twilight seep into through the
Either ‘into’ or ‘through’, but not both

But the experience was, well, less than memorable.
Try: But the experience was - well - less than memorable. (the dash provides more emphasis than the comma)

from the start, but only emotionally, not sexually.
Try: from the start - but only emotionally, not sexually. (the dash provides more emphasis than the comma)

is tha despitethat ( ... )

Reply

Re: Comments from an editor triplescorpio August 7 2010, 18:10:55 UTC
I really appreciate your comments and will use them as I plan to restructure this piece at some point. Annie is a recurring character that I use; I realize I glossed over some points in the narrative which I'll flesh out later - I was pressed for time with the deadline. I feel your comments were very perceptive and I appreciate the time you took with my story.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up