(Untitled)

Oct 21, 2007 10:47

1. Soooo, Gay!Dumbledore has made fandom_wank.

2. And some amusing icons over at userpicks3. I'm seeing a lot of complaints that "OMG, it's not explicitly stated in the book! Damn that Rowling bitch!" This from some of the same people who complain that when it comes to romance, Rowling tends to tell instead of show. (An assertion with which I tend ( Read more... )

hp: deathly hallows

Leave a comment

Comments 45

ballyharnon October 21 2007, 16:15:30 UTC
asdf;lkjfa;lskdfj;alkdsjfalkdkfjaldksjalkdj!!!!!!!!1one

I AM DEAD WITH LAUGHING AND RIGHTEOUSNESS!!!

Reply

thistlerose October 21 2007, 16:17:34 UTC
At the icons, I take it? There's one in the comments that made me laugh out loud.

Reply

ballyharnon October 21 2007, 16:19:38 UTC
asdakafkadsaf!!!!1

Reply

ballyharnon October 21 2007, 16:21:13 UTC
ZOMG. I wrote a fic, though, click my journal, hee, it's not funny at all. or related to this or anything. but still.

Reply


cruisedirector October 21 2007, 16:16:07 UTC
*applauds*

*needs a "Dumbledore's Army" icon*

Reply

thistlerose October 21 2007, 16:17:58 UTC
*bows*

Reply


iulia_linnea October 21 2007, 16:18:36 UTC
I agree with you about Dumbles; I also think that, to Rowling, the fact that she always saw him as gay was no big deal to her-that is pretty cool, in my opinion.

Reply

thistlerose October 21 2007, 20:39:58 UTC
Definitely.

Reply


themis October 21 2007, 16:22:55 UTC
Hah, I've been refreshing FW since I heard the news. :D

Those icons are...fabulous! Thanks for linking.

Reply

thistlerose October 21 2007, 20:40:28 UTC
I can't believe it took a whole day to make F-W. My goodness, fandom. Getting slow!

You're welcome! :)

Reply


rwday October 21 2007, 17:00:34 UTC
I honestly don't get the controversy. Dumbledore's sexuality, whether het, gay or bi, isn't really relevant to the story Rowling was trying to tell. Yes, she focused on the (heterosexual) relationships of the trio, but that was because it's Harry's story and those relationships were ongoing and current. The last few books were long enough without adding in extraneous material about Dumbledore's sex life from sixty years ago or more.

Reply

thistlerose October 21 2007, 20:40:53 UTC
Exactly.

Reply

sweill October 21 2007, 21:17:54 UTC
WORD.
We don't here jack about any of Professor McGonagal's love interests. They could be feline for all we know.

I think anyone who gets pissed off about it has their OWN issues to deal with.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up