(Untitled)

Apr 07, 2010 07:29

Should I feel bad that doing my job sometimes means that murderers and other types of law-breakers have gone free or have received a lesser sentence than they likely would have otherwise ( Read more... )

karla sofen

Leave a comment

Comments 146

aequitastwin April 7 2010, 21:49:37 UTC
Aye. You should.

Reply

drmoonstone April 8 2010, 04:40:31 UTC
And on the chance that I don't?

Reply

aequitastwin April 8 2010, 06:05:26 UTC
A good person wouldn't be comfortable with what you've done.

You're asking this question, though, doesn't that mean some part of you doubts it?

Reply

drmoonstone April 8 2010, 07:32:56 UTC
Maybe. There are things that come before my own personal feelings though, so being comfortable with it is a bit relative.

Reply


notmatahari April 8 2010, 07:19:41 UTC
Does it matter if you should or shouldn't? You seem to be fairly unapologetic on the matter.

Reply

drmoonstone April 8 2010, 07:30:30 UTC
It's my job, so I'll do it regardless of my feelings.

Reply

notmatahari April 8 2010, 07:38:44 UTC
And what are your feelings, exactly? Forgive me, I'm just curious.

Reply

drmoonstone April 9 2010, 05:41:19 UTC
I do my job, I get paid, I continue to keep a roof over my head and food on my table. That's good enough for me.

If the person really is troubled, then I have an obligation to help them. It's troubling that a diagnosis can aid someone unjust, but that's out of my hands, and in those of the men that use it.

Reply


sideshowboss April 8 2010, 21:52:45 UTC
I think many people, Doctor, would disagree with your argument that being in an institution constitutes freedom.

Reply

drmoonstone April 9 2010, 05:45:13 UTC
[There are a few letters that are hastily scratched out, as if she's deciding just how to approach the conversation with him this time.]

I think that others could agree that temporary internment with therapy and pills is much better than life in prison, with steel bars and killers.

Reply

sideshowboss April 9 2010, 06:06:51 UTC
It isn't often "temporary." And the state of the mental hospitals is really quite ghastly, it's unfortunate. Not everyone would rather risk a lobotomy. But that's perhaps what a great deal of criminals deserve.

Reply

drmoonstone April 9 2010, 06:11:26 UTC
I couldn't agree more! Of course, it's never always institutionalization. There are some very talents lawyers these days.

Reply


couldbeavoided April 8 2010, 21:54:29 UTC
But there is "normal" and there's "crazy." Not everyone is crazy.

Reply

drmoonstone April 9 2010, 05:45:57 UTC
Not everyone is crazy, but I don't think anybody is normal.

Reply

couldbeavoided April 9 2010, 06:08:51 UTC
Why not?

Reply

drmoonstone April 9 2010, 06:12:29 UTC
"Normal" is only skin-deep.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up