Save or Delete

Jul 24, 2009 20:07


Title
Save or Delete

Short, concise description of the idea
Make a difference between buttons "Save Entry" and "Delete Entry"

Full description of the ideaAfter editing the entry, user have to choose between two buttons to submit it - "Save Entry" or "Delete Entry". They look the same ( Read more... )

entry editor, user interface, entry deletion, usability, entry editing, § no status

Leave a comment

Comments 17

lady_angelina August 8 2009, 23:12:26 UTC
If you accidentally click on the "Delete" button, you should get a dialogue box that asks you for confirmation. Only if you're extra quick on the draw would I find this insufficient protection against accidental deletion.

So, I personally don't really see a need for this.

Reply

kayt_arminta August 8 2009, 23:14:31 UTC
I didn't know it prompted you to ask if you were sure, that's good to know, I can relax a little, then yeah, I don't see a point to this either. Unless you're beyond clueless and just click Okay because they usually do.

Reply

lady_angelina August 8 2009, 23:17:59 UTC
Hmmm... if you're not getting the confirmation dialogue at all for whatever reason, then yes, the might be a need for this after all. ^^

And I forgot to point out that regardless, I don't see how this would harm anything (except to possibly disorient people at first who are used to aiming their cursor a certain way, much like you're used to dialing familiar phone numbers, etc.).

Reply

misspretender August 10 2009, 17:52:54 UTC
I wouldn't click on delete button if there were a distinction.

Haven't you deleted your posts or documents accidentally even after confurmation?

Reply


kayt_arminta August 8 2009, 23:12:43 UTC
Interesting suggestion. I'd go for it, just because I've almost deleted posts by accident before just because of that

Reply


azurelunatic August 8 2009, 23:34:48 UTC
As long as the tab order is the same, and the contrast is good, coloring them wouldn't hurt anything (and wouldn't change things for colorblind users). I know I've almost hit the wrong one more than once.

Reply

xnera August 9 2009, 14:44:06 UTC
Not opposed to coloring the buttons, but I'd prefer if the Save button was made "bold" instead. That would make it stand out more, plus it would have no impact on colorblind users.

Reply

azurelunatic August 9 2009, 16:04:58 UTC
I like that! (And perhaps "more impact" to colorblind users?)

Reply

girlfight August 9 2009, 17:06:59 UTC
I like this.

Reply


cos August 9 2009, 01:45:40 UTC
Doesn't seem that important as long as delete requires confirmation.

Reply


mordyn4 August 9 2009, 02:20:46 UTC
Good idea, I've almost done it. I click through those confirmation pages on autopilot sometimes.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up