Add them as a friend?

Feb 08, 2008 14:54


Title
Add them as a friend?

Short, concise description of the idea
The phrase "Add them as a friend" in the gray navigation bar is awkward.

Full description of the idea
"Them" refers to two or more people. It's awkward to see a single user referred to as a "them" instead of "him or her".
An ordered list of benefits

friends management, site copy, § no status

Leave a comment

Comments 18

exdream_ February 26 2008, 19:29:20 UTC
I think it is a gender neutral pronoun.

Reply


neitherday February 26 2008, 19:38:44 UTC
The singular they is gender neutral. Unlike many gender neutral alternatives, the singular they is not a modern creation and can be found in literature from Shakespeare to Jane Austin.

While there is debate about whether or not the singular they is grammatically correct, its usage is growing.

Reply

beginning February 26 2008, 19:41:22 UTC
There's debate? I always thought it was just flat-out "wrong." (Not that I really care; I'll keep using it.) Damn, now I have to go Google...

Reply


beginning February 26 2008, 19:39:12 UTC
While technically incorrect, it's the generally agreed-upon gender-neutral pronoun for English, and we should keep it for that reason.

Reply


desh February 26 2008, 20:12:35 UTC
I'm very much in the descriptive camp that considers "them" to not be incorrect usage in a situation like this. But that's not really the point; the point is that there's an easy rewording that's not awkward at all (not the "him or her" one, but the other ones you proposed) and that avoids this very argument, which can reach holy-war proportions these days. So I'm all in favor of the suggestion.

Reply

october_logic February 26 2008, 20:35:58 UTC
Well, one could argue that having it the way it is prompts discussion and thus educates people that it's an accepted (if not entirely grammatically correct) gender-neutral term. I actually wasn't aware of that fact and appreciate the information. :)

However, I'm not opposed to the change. :)

Reply


dandelion February 26 2008, 20:36:19 UTC
Only the benefit of less English speakers confusing him, her, and them.
I think you mean fewer English speakers, if we're going to get into grammar pedantry and prescriptivism.

Reply

piecs February 26 2008, 20:37:35 UTC
Oh. Oops.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up