Wow.

Apr 02, 2010 14:52

Finished I Am Legend. Still don't like it ( Read more... )

wtf, reviews

Leave a comment

Comments 24

jumpthesnark April 2 2010, 22:46:28 UTC
Yeah, I didn't like those. He basically wanted to be Edgar Allen Poe. It... didn't work out so well for him.

Reply

strangecreature April 2 2010, 22:49:55 UTC
It was just seeming so painfully gratuitous! Checking out his bio, it looks like he was a writer for The Twilight Zone too, which does explain the proclivity for Big Twist endings, at least. (Did you manage to get through the whole thing? Kudos, dude. I've officially given up on it, unfortunately.)

Reply


coniferous_you April 2 2010, 22:51:47 UTC
So, the whole book was basically just shock-value without a real point?

Reply

strangecreature April 2 2010, 22:57:25 UTC
The phrase 'shaggy dog tale gone wrong' does spring to mind. :-P I quite liked the idea of I Am Legend, even if the execution was kind of painful, but the shorter stories after it in the book didn't even seem to be throwing the reader a bit of plot before the shock-value ending.

Reply

coniferous_you April 2 2010, 23:00:24 UTC
I almost want to say it's cultural conditioning. I mean, a lot of Canadian fiction IS pretty shocking, but there's always some meaning.

And, also, zombievampires WITHOUT social commentary? That's just wrong.

Reply

strangecreature April 2 2010, 23:04:51 UTC
Even if it gets a little buried under symbolism at times. *G*

I feel the need to clarify! The whole book is called I Am Legend, but that's also the name of the first short story in the book. And there's plenty of meaning in that one; I just didn't like it because of the main character. After that one, there are other stories not in the zombievampire universe. The one I quoted from up there is Nearly Departed. And it was three pages long and entirely without social commentary, beyond perhaps 'first degree murder is funny when it's your wife!'

Reply


Leave a comment

Up