Pink & Gray review (spoiler free)

Feb 20, 2012 21:59

My personal Pink & Gray review
SPOILER FREE

Read more... )

personal, pink & gray, members: kato shigeaki

Leave a comment

Comments 75

Thanks meriwa_kato March 1 2012, 22:22:46 UTC
Hey girl ! Thank you so much for the review!

I'm a great fan of Shige (for a long time now xD) and I really want to read his book, but, well, first I don't live in japan and last I can't read and speak japanese.... so I know that I probably never get the chance to read it by myself (like a lot of his foreign fan), and I'm raelly Happy when I found reviews about "P&G" (bad or nice critism, just comment about his work pleased me^^).
Your post was clear and well writen (I think I understand your feeling and the global vision you have of the book, your comments were really pleasant to read)
I hope to find more reviews of Shige's book ^^

Well I hope you'll understand what I write and I'm really sorry for my poor English ><

take care~

*PS: Sorry to ask you that but, I just read your comment so I could not read your resume, do you think you can send it by MP to me ? If not, ok don't worry I understand*
*PS2 [the last one ><] :I would like to ask (if you have time and if my poor english is not a too big inconvenient): do you mean to talk ( ... )

Reply

Re: Thanks spilledmilk25 March 1 2012, 22:26:59 UTC
Thank you very much for the comment! I was very happy reading it >< Did you find other reviews? I didn't go to search them too much~

About the summary I'm ok with that, I'll send you the file by DM now :) So we can talk about that! (I love to talk about P&G XDD)

Reply

Re: Thanks meriwa_kato March 1 2012, 22:49:14 UTC
Really!! you make my day !! (well my nignt, to be true, it's nearly minuit in France xD)

Thank you again then :D
I'll love to talk with you by DM but... what's DM?? >__< (shame on me).
And I can't wait for your talk about it ^^

For the other review (sorry I don't have the link) I just find court comments about it on the net (I search in google).
And I just realize that all of the informations/translation I read on the book was mostly post by you on lj >< (once again shame on me :p)

Reply

Re: Thanks spilledmilk25 March 1 2012, 22:51:56 UTC
It's quite midnight here too :DD (Well of course, I'm in Italy :P)
Oh DM is the private message here on LiveJournal you should have received an email notification about my message >w< You can reply me there if you want! Or in my user info there are my twitter/FB/etc contacts :)

Yes, once only I tried to google the novel and...my lj came out all the times XD I'm happy about that! ♥_♥

Reply


thanks for your review :) la_gavotte April 10 2012, 11:30:07 UTC
Hey, I happened to find this journal as I was browsing for Shige novel's news on google.

As novel reader, it amuses me when I heard that Shige has published a novel & I'm really curious about it. Since I can't read Japanese it's kinda impossible for me to read the novel.

Your review is like an answer to most of my questions *seriously*. After I read your review, I think Pink and Gray is a good book and I'm really happy to know that he did well. ^_^v

I hope this book will be a hit! Ganbatte Shige!

Reply

Re: thanks for your review :) spilledmilk25 April 10 2012, 12:05:08 UTC
Hello ^^ I'm glad you bumped here in your search and I'm happy you liked it and got a good impression of the book :)
Thank you!

Reply

Re: thanks for your review :) la_gavotte April 10 2012, 13:27:40 UTC
Yes, it really left a good impression on me. :)
Too bad I'm too late to read your detail resume. But it's OK since I heard there will be a drama adaptation, I will wait until then to know the whole story.

P.S: I'm now enjoying some of your Shige's Pink and Gray-related translations, so thank you again. ^^

Reply


tokyocinema April 11 2012, 12:17:48 UTC
Thanks for your review! I'd love to read the review with spoilers, but it was f-locked before I found your review T____T

It sounds so lovely. I need to work on my japanese more because it sounds like a goooooood read :D

Reply


princesssasuke January 31 2013, 10:10:10 UTC
Hello!
I read your review and I became interested in whole book. Could please open your review with spoilers for a day or something? Because I won't be able to read it for long time and I'm really curious about it. Thank you

Reply

spilledmilk25 January 31 2013, 17:03:25 UTC
I added you so you should now be able to read the post ^^ If not let me know! :)

Reply


tamoi2233 February 8 2013, 03:22:42 UTC
hi! i would really like to read the plot post... is there any way that i can??

Reply

spilledmilk25 February 8 2013, 16:42:16 UTC
Hello, I will add you to my friends list so that you can read the post~

Reply


Leave a comment

Up