Comments | shounenbattle: ROUND 2 FINAL RESULTS

flashily in shounenbattle

ROUND 2 FINAL RESULTS

Sep 13, 2010 04:06

All right, the part I'm sure you've all been waiting for - the results. We have our winners!

( With no further ado... the final results. )

results, !round 02, challenge10

Comments 68

vai_rin September 13 2010, 08:09:18 UTC

Congrats winners, awesome participants for this round 8D

astrokittie September 13 2010, 08:09:27 UTC

Woooooooooooo! IT WAS SO MUCH FUN PARTYING WITH ALL OF YOU! Congratulations to snm_queen (I KNEW IT WAS YOU!!!) and mystical_touch!

I would like my final critiques, please! I don't care if you screen them or not.

YOU WERE AWESOME flashily September 13 2010, 08:13:40 UTC

Set Placement:2nd place (+2pts) SET B - crit (optional ( ... )

Re: YOU WERE AWESOME astrokittie September 13 2010, 08:15:39 UTC

Oh man, truest words ever spoken on the set B crit.

Thank you!

snm_queen September 13 2010, 10:22:13 UTC

LOL HOW? I wish I had figured out who you were so quickly! I couldn't tell until the third round, because who else would icon JoJo's Bizarre Adventures ♥ and omg fucking gorgeous typography on the extra icon. Hell, I wasn't even 100% sure if kawaii_chicken was who I thought it was until...oh, challenge 6. /FAIL

Thread 33

pamkips September 13 2010, 09:00:06 UTC

I KNEW IT.

flashily September 13 2010, 09:04:32 UTC

LOL yeah. I wish I could have said "Yeah, it's them, you're so clever!" But I couldn't.

pamkips September 13 2010, 09:08:59 UTC

IK IK, ouch. I know everyone figured it out before me *cough*astrokittie but I just wanted to know. ;3;

flashily September 13 2010, 09:11:51 UTC

I can't tell you how many times astrokittie said she thought Askeladd was snm_queen and how many times I had to tell her I couldn't say.

Thread 13

pamkips September 13 2010, 09:01:03 UTC

Also congrats to the winners, I'm glad I figured out who 2 of you were.

snm_queen September 13 2010, 11:53:46 UTC

Thanks and same to you for getting as far as you did! Next round, Astro, you, and me in the finals. BRING IT. I spent forever trying to figure out who the last person was.

pamkips September 13 2010, 22:09:57 UTC

IS THAT A CHALLENGE? VERY WELL THEN. LET'S MAKE TO IT IN mangabattle~

me too

snm_queen September 14 2010, 00:40:50 UTC

And everywhere else since I know us LIMS addicts are in all of the ones going on right now lawl!

Thread 6

snm_queen September 13 2010, 10:17:43 UTC

Ahhhh, all you people on the West Coast, posting when I'm sleeping!! lol

HOMFG, EEEEE!! THANK YOU AND CONGRATS TO ASTROKITTIE AND mystical_touch!!

You two were tough competition, when I finally figured out who Astro was I was all FFFFFUUUUUUU for the Tryptich theme b/c I remember her shoujo_battle one was FUCKING GORGEOUS. Omg, I feel like this kitty right now lol, best way to start my day! And it rhymes, how gay~!

Oh yeah, completely forgot, unscreened crits for Set C please & thank you! lol Still kinda sleepy.

flashily September 13 2010, 10:21:01 UTC

fegkuregtiwetr that cat.

AND CONGRATS. OMG YOUR ICONS WERE SO PRETTY ALL ROUND AND SAKLKJDKAJD ♥

Set Placement:
1st place (+3pts) SET C - This set is amazing. Everything fits well together, every step thought out; crop, color, typography. The selective color works very well too, because it goes with the text. Nicely thought out, and looking aesthetically beautiful in the end.
1st place (+3pts) SET C - I like that it looks like a 'set' of three and they each share a theme, but are different enough to stand on their own.
1st place (+3pts) SET C - I wanna have bbs with this set from how amazing it is. The text usage is phenomenal, as is the texture usage. The select coloring on it is a great idea as well which works amazingly. It's an incredibly creative & cohesive set that's just amazing. TEE HEE ICU.1st place (+3pts) SET C - First of all, I love the croppings in this set, and I love the compositions in all three icons ( ... )

snm_queen September 13 2010, 11:06:43 UTC

Isn't it! Most adorable :O face ever.

THAAAAAANK YOUUUUUUU! It was lots of fun competing here, I loved your themes, even whey I had no idea what to do with them. Though those provided textures were evil. As was kinda-sorta the last theme. And lol, thanks but naw, I def had my dry spells of OMG WTF TO DOOOO?? /THROW AN ICON TOGETHER AT THE LAST MINUTE <-WHICH HAPPENED ALL THE TIME DIDN'T IT SOB

flashily September 13 2010, 11:21:53 UTC

It is! It's like CHII in real life.

Thank you! That means a lot as this was seriously the first time I've run an icontest, let alone a LIMS. (Though I've participated in a few). So I was always so nervous that people wouldn't like the themes and dksaljak I know the last two challenges were evil, but it was the cream of the crop! I had to be a little evil! XD And yeah, you were pretty consistently last to submit.

Thread 8