Results: Round 3 // Challenge 8

[hsapiens]

Banner maker this week is mesmerising.

My favorite voter comment this week:
"I kid you not, the very moment I viewed the entries for the first time, I exclaimed, "*(&%*%-*^$&%^. Bleep!" And then muttered a bit (crazily) to myself about the continued impossibility of picking favorites and unfavorites. You all are stupendous. I don't even

Comments

[beeej]

+ 11: A beautiful use of black and white, and lovely clean quality to this icon. Love the idea to blend the two images. The blending is flawless

[twister_pants]

I'm not sure which icon number was mine and it seems Scrapbook is still down so the icons aren't showing on the voting page. I think I might have been 29.

Unscreened comments are fine whenever we know it's mine for sure.

[hsapiens]

Yup; you're number 29. Thank heavens I save the icons with your position number and names attached. BTW, your icon was a-ma-zing. Love it to little pieces.

[twister_pants]

Thank you :D

[beeej]

- 29: There's too much empty space in the icon which looks almost white.
- 29: (This image just doesn't work in blakc & white, the whole thing looks like a mass of spilt ink.)
- 29: I don't understand the idea for this icon. I don't even know who the people are. :(
+ 29: really like the texture and general tone of the icon
+ 29: (the textures make this black and white icon bold and stand out, i love it!)
+ 29: A very nicely rendered visualization of the emotion behind the image - the shading and contrast are just right.
+ 29: Lovely use of textures, and black and white.
+ 29: The texture used transforms what could have been a boring icon into something breathtaking. The slight asymmetry is what does it, really.

"29: I like the background of the icon a lot, and the placement of the subjects is good. Also, it somehow reminds me of X-Files. x)"

[beeej]

+ 1: Great use of negative space, text and contrast. The creativity blows me away. Great job :)
+ 1: Great use of text
+ 1: The text is perfectly placed, the use of black and white seems especially appropriate since Adria and the Ori see everything in black and white. Nicely cropped too.
+ 1: Lovely. Great font and placement of text. Black and white was a great choice, nice amount of contrast.
+ 1: (The text looks gorgeous on the icon. Nice contract and composition.)
+ 1: wonderful B&W white and text choice and positioning; excellent.
+ 1: Love the text, the crop, the b&w, and the excellent contrast that brings out Adria.
+ 1: Great levels on your black and white and I love the text at the top. Everything works!

"1: Pretty b&w and good use of the text."

[rightxhere]

I'm not sure what my number was either lol But could I have comments, prefer where others can't see if possible, thanks.

Fun challenge...and a challenge it was! lol Only regret is I couldn't vote last night (I typically try to vote on my Thursday) because our phone + internet were out :(

Loved the icons this round, though. Blew me away!

#12

[hsapiens]

Your entry number... :)

Re: #12

[rightxhere]

Thanks :) Comments screened for #12 then please :) lol

[magnavox_23]

I can't get the icons to load either. I think mine was #2?

#2

[hsapiens]

Your entry number. :)

Re: #2

[magnavox_23]

Sweet, can I have those comments unscreened, thankyou. :)

Re: #2

[beeej]

- 2: The sickly green coloring is really not flattering, though I do like the yeti concept