Comments | severina2001: American Idol -- Top 6

severina2001

American Idol -- Top 6

Apr 22, 2008 21:19

Top 6 - the songs of Andrew Lloyd Webber.

( Top 6 - Andrew Lloyd Webber Week )

Comments 40

(The comment has been removed)

severina2001 April 23 2008, 01:34:58 UTC

What kills me is that this is the third time Brooke has done that (once in Hollywood Week, once earlier in the season at the piano, and then today.) It's unacceptable to me. If you can't learn half of ONE SONG in a week, even with everything else that's going on, you're not cut out for this. She's going to sob like a baby when she's finally eliminated.

(The comment has been removed)

severina2001 April 23 2008, 02:20:44 UTC

At least she didn't talk back to the judges tonight. :|

(The comment has been removed)

severina2001 April 23 2008, 01:36:14 UTC

I should Youtube the original. I guess David A succeeded at what he wanted to do, because it sounded exactly like a disposable pop ballad to me.

sydneyalexis April 23 2008, 03:26:07 UTC

Webber composed Phantom for his wife at the time -- Sarah Brightman.

This version is a little faster than normal and the cadenza at the ending is totally different than what the original score, but it's a decent enough version for you to get a sense of what it supposed to sound like.

[Think of Me - YouTube]

severina2001 April 26 2008, 13:20:12 UTC

I knew that he was married to Sarah and that she starred in Phantom, but had no idea that he wrote it for her.

joesther April 23 2008, 01:35:29 UTC

It's ALW week? OK, this one I'm going to watch.

I'm a total ALW fangirl and I know his music. I know it. So if anyone fucks any of his songs up, I will be pissed. off. You don't fuck with ALW.

Me? Opinionated? Why do you ask? ;)

severina2001 April 23 2008, 01:37:39 UTC

Apparently David A. completely changes up "Think Of You". I don't know the original so I couldn't judge, but he makes it a disposable pop ballad. You'll probably hate it. Watch and see!

joesther April 23 2008, 01:39:49 UTC

Oh god. If he changes it, I'm going to hurt someone. Seriously.

You. Don't. Change. ALW. Songs. You just don't. It's like spitting on your place of worship. Or... whatever.

I'll watch, but then I'll have to come back and vent. You gonna be around?

severina2001 April 23 2008, 02:18:30 UTC

I'm off to work in about fifteen minutes, but feel free to vent anyway and I'll be back tomorrow. :D

Thread 15

flamencanyc April 23 2008, 01:37:15 UTC

I want Carly off this show so fucking badly. And I don't even hate her the way you do.

severina2001 April 23 2008, 01:38:25 UTC

She was shouty and completely off the melody. And I know we're going to be stuck with her another week. ARGH.

severina2001 April 26 2008, 13:26:17 UTC

JOIN ME IN THE CELEBRATIONS!!!

shadownyc April 23 2008, 02:27:01 UTC

Me, too. My work colleague and I are convinced there's a fix and she's sleeping her way through TPTB.

Thread 6

loud99 April 23 2008, 01:45:27 UTC

Brooke needs to go. That was proven after tonight.

David A. turned that song into elevator music.

I actually really liked Carly's performance. She did a good job.

I hate Syesha, so everything she sings I'm going to hate before it begins.

Jason, I'm torn because he's so pretty and I just like looking at him (lol), but he did look a bit uncomfortable tonight.

And David C., he is just awesome in every way. Best performance of the night, hands down.

severina2001 April 23 2008, 02:19:26 UTC

Elevator music. Yes. Thank you.

Your Syesha hate is like my Carly hate.