American Idol Top 8

Apr 08, 2008 21:13

Top 8 )

tv: american idol

Leave a comment

Comments 14

shadownyc April 9 2008, 01:27:26 UTC
Michael Johns is definitely getting better with every performance. He totally captured me with his song.

Syesha & Kristy were both surprisingly good this week.

I found Jason's rendition of Somewhere Over the Rainbow quite moving.

David C. and Carly were both pretty bad this week.

Brooke was boring...definitely no Carole King.

David A. was sweet and moving and he certainly is passionate about singing.

I would bet that the bottom 3 with be David C., Brooke & Carly.

Reply

severina2001 April 9 2008, 12:55:14 UTC
You're still watching! *squee*

I seem to be in the minority about Jason. I just disliked that version quite a bit. But it certainly looks like everyone is praising it over at TwoP so I think he's gonna be safe.

Reply

shadownyc April 9 2008, 16:10:47 UTC
My colleague at work hated Jason's song...you have a partner. LOL

Reply


kitasangel April 9 2008, 01:47:29 UTC
Again why do people feel they can sing Freddie? It is not called lets sing Queen each week. I don't like Kristy please make her go away. Michael was good tonight. I liked Jason. What was David Cook doing I could understand what he was singing. Carley don't like her and can't seem to over come it so if she gets voted off no problem.

Reply

severina2001 April 9 2008, 12:55:56 UTC
Re: Freddie. I KNOW! That drives me batty. Freddie is more off limits to me than those divas like Mariah Carey.

Reply


loud99 April 9 2008, 01:54:51 UTC
Jason Castro took the night, hands down. His performance was amazing. And I'm not even a big fan (I just think he's v. v. pretty. lol).

David Cook is my guy, but I was really disappointed in him tonight. The choir backup destroyed his entire performance. I'm hoping he just temp. lost his mind and next week he'll be back to normal.

And I pretty much agree with what you said about the others. Although, I think the bottom three will be all girls, I'm just not sure which three.

Reply

severina2001 April 9 2008, 12:57:12 UTC
Jason is definitely v.v. pretty. But I wasn't feeling that performance at all. I am clearly in the minority, though.

I think that Syesha might end up in the bottom 3 in place of Jason, and might go home (even though Carly *should*!)

Reply


(The comment has been removed)

severina2001 April 9 2008, 12:58:45 UTC
I know what you mean... I, however, force my co-worker to listen to me blather about the show. :D

I think David A. looks really calm and confident when he's singing, but waiting for the judges comments he looks terrified. And considering he was on Star Search and all, that's just kind of weird. I sincerely hope the Stage Dad rumours aren't true.

Reply


(The comment has been removed)

severina2001 April 9 2008, 13:00:23 UTC
I enjoyed the night again, but it was like I got dropped in to Opposite World. I thought KLC and Syesha did well, and disliked Jason and David Cook. Weird.

If I ever like Carly, I'm going to go off and have a lobotomy or something.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up