Leave a comment

Comments 39

findmyantidrug May 9 2009, 05:47:45 UTC
This is so amazing, there's no words. Just. Wow. Fantastic. I've been thinking about doing a fic about Roche, but now that I know this is out there, that's one less bunny I'm gonna worry about. No way anything could top this. Just. Yeah. Wow. Added to my memories like woah, and. Oh man that last line, and the slow descent, and...gorgeous.

Reply

scarlet_carsons May 9 2009, 12:30:38 UTC
Daww. *blushes* Ahem. Thank you!

I'm surprised there aren't more fics about the Roche case, really, given that Rorschach is such a popular character, and it's a huge turning point in his life.

Reply


brancher May 9 2009, 05:51:44 UTC
This is a masterpiece. The writing's professional-grade, with the amazingly unreliable narrator; and you've told me things about Rorschach and about Walter I never knew before. Brilliant.

Reply

scarlet_carsons May 9 2009, 12:39:35 UTC
Awww shit man, I'm going to get a case of Writer's Ego. Thank you. :D

Reply


quietprofanity May 9 2009, 15:27:04 UTC
This fanfic is incredibly impressive. I love the bits with the journal (and the last line), his thoughts about Jasmin, the mice ... it's really great. So visceral. I can tell you put a lot of work into it and it was well worth it. Great work.

Reply

scarlet_carsons May 10 2009, 23:21:59 UTC
Thank you. :)

Reply


carnageincminor May 10 2009, 01:33:19 UTC
Oh wow, this was simply mindblowingly amazing.

I loved the little insights into Rorschach's mind, such as how he really feels about his interrogation technique, the journals, and all the little points where he reflects on society. The level of detail is superb and I totally respect the amount of research you did to make it realistic. The Roche case I think has always been hard to write for, and yours does a fantastic job of giving a much fuller and extensive backstory than many others out there.

And I love the change of perspective in the last line.

Thank you for writing this! It's beautiful.

Reply

scarlet_carsons May 10 2009, 23:29:27 UTC
Thank you!

Doing research is probably the most enjoyable bit about writing for me, weirdly. (The next most enjoyable bit would be coming up with silly similes for things. Similes are awesome.)

Reply


i_am_your_spy May 10 2009, 03:05:00 UTC
This is amazing. I love his increasing detachment and the way you don't shy away from the nasty bits of his character.

Reply

scarlet_carsons May 10 2009, 23:44:27 UTC
Thanks! IMO, Rorschach wouldn't be half as interesting without his nasty bits. I wasn't sure if I'd made him enough of a douchebag, because anti heroes always seem kind of badass and cool, and I didn't want to lose sight of the fact that he could be a messed-up little bully. (Who shuts old men in refrigerators.)

Reply


Leave a comment

Up