Leave a comment

Comments 21

pinkyapples October 27 2012, 22:05:06 UTC
Really liked your usage of the special kids and giving them a wonderful home like the Magic Menagarie. Loved your Gabriel here and Balthazar. Did have me thinking of the vampires apprentice (or whatever the book/movie is called) but that isn't a bad thing. enjoyed it.

Reply

reticentric October 28 2012, 05:44:39 UTC
I've never seen the movie but I've heard of it and always thought it looked interesting. :) I'm glad you enjoyed the fic!

Reply


romeo_ambiences October 28 2012, 19:22:13 UTC
The idea of Gabriel taking in "strays" was heartwarming and immediately hooked me.

And it was amazing that Dean didn't think Cas was a freak. Does make me wonder what Sam and Jess will think.

Zachariah was vile. Ew. And Anna was scary in her rabidity.

Loved all those in the menagerie. It made me sad that Cas was leaving this "real family"
behind even though, yes, he should be with Dean.

Thank you for sharing. I truly enjoyed the read.

Reply

reticentric October 29 2012, 02:46:55 UTC
Thank you so much for reading; I really appreciate it and I'm glad you enjoyed it hehe.

Reply


ganeshalemming November 2 2012, 02:41:07 UTC
Wonderful story! Loved it when Castiel started whaling on Zachariah. Guy can hold his own. You did a wonderful job setting the whole scene of the Menagerie, what kind of place it was, the people there, how it functioned... I was really pulled in. Beautiful!

Reply

reticentric November 3 2012, 07:10:34 UTC
I'm glad you could picture things so clearly. Half the reason the fic is so long is because I wanted to be sure people could see everything and that it made sense hehehe. Thank you so much for reading! =)

Reply


the_diggler May 28 2013, 11:45:22 UTC
I didn't know what to expect from the fic, but every moment was fantastic. Your characterizations were great and the world you created was really wonderful and really sucked me in. I adored every minute of this <3

Reply

reticentric May 29 2013, 11:02:29 UTC
Yay! I'm very happy that you gave it a chance and that you enjoyed it! Thank you so much for reading and reviewing! XD

Reply

the_diggler May 30 2013, 02:44:57 UTC
Okay, so maybe I was a bit speechless after reading this that I didn't convey my feels as accurately as I would have liked.... I was ADDICTED to this fic, as soon as I started reading it. I mean, I was looking for excuses to get away and read it, to the point that I was reading it on my phone in front of my relatives who were visiting from out-of-town. And I never read stuff on my phone at all to begin with. And as soon as they left I stayed up all night to finish it... which is probably why I was so inarticulate before :S

I don't often rec things either, but this is something I'm going to rec for life. Not only was it good, thought-out writing, but it had that - dare I say it - X factor? Heart? Magic? It was amazing and it's something I know I'm going to read and re-read forever. Just wanted you to know <3

Reply

reticentric May 31 2013, 10:09:26 UTC
Wow! Seriously I...man if you could see my face right now you'd probably think something was wrong with me with how much I'm smiling lol.

I'm pretty speechless right about now but, really I thank you so much from like the bottom of my heart for your kind words. I've only did 2 Dean/Cas fics (working on a 3rd right now, another DCBB) and to be honest I'm still sorta terrified because there is so much good stuff out there so to know you enjoyed it to the level you did makes me feel so good and so much braver about putting my next D/C out there.

So again thank you so much; you've given me such a boost in confidence for my 3rd go! XD <3

Reply


Leave a comment

Up