The Therapist-to-be is IN (diagnosing fictional characters)

Oct 17, 2011 16:49

I am taking a class on Treatment and Assessment. Yes, MFTs can diagnose. (We can't prescribe medication ( Read more... )

psychology: therapy for the fictional, psychology

Leave a comment

Comments 84

naomikritzer October 18 2011, 00:14:01 UTC
Belinda from Georgette Heyer's The Foundling. Belinda (a foundling) is startlingly naive and gullible, and will go with nearly anyone who says "if you come with me, I will buy you a diamond ring!" or some similar bribe. She also has a short attention span and a poor memory.

(Is this the sort of thing you're thinking of? Belinda came to mind because I was trying to diagnose Belinda while reading this book, and came up with some theories. I'm curious if yours match mine, if you've read this book. I picked up Heyer because of Jo Walton's post about her, here: http://papersky.livejournal.com/27014.html ... I can definitely see the influences on Bujold, having read Bujold, when reading Heyer.)

Reply

rachelmanija October 18 2011, 00:15:23 UTC
That is exactly the sort of thing I was thinking of, but alas, I have not read The Foundling. I will let you know what I think when I do read it, though!

Reply

naomikritzer October 18 2011, 00:26:21 UTC
Heyer's books are filled with characters who invite speculative diagnosis, FYI. Cotillion has a character, Dolphinton, who has some sort of developmental delay (maybe; no one's quite sure what's up, they're just all quite sure there is SOMETHING off about him). The one I am reading now, The Nonesuch, has a teenage girl who is almost uncontrollable by her relatives and also startlingly selfish (even by teenage standards).

Reply

rachelmanija October 18 2011, 00:28:33 UTC
I love Cotillion. I will definitely assess Dolphinton the next time I re-read it.

Reply


lady_ganesh October 18 2011, 00:29:20 UTC
I believe this meme was made for Heero Yuy. If you feel you've spent too many days of your life trying to analyze him already, I can come up with someone else, or you can choose a Gundam cast member that appeals.

Reply

rachelmanija October 18 2011, 00:31:04 UTC
Indeed! Watch for a (brief) formal assessment of him at my leisure.

Reply

rachelmanija October 18 2011, 00:32:35 UTC
PS. I have been watching Weiss Kreutz, which also has multiple characters who seem naturals for this game.

Reply

lady_ganesh October 18 2011, 00:35:40 UTC
I am sorry, and also utterly delighted. Tsukiyono Omi, especially if you make it through to Gluhen, would keep you busy for days.

Reply


klwilliams October 18 2011, 00:33:03 UTC
What about Barbara Hambly's Antryg Windrose? Or Dorothy Dunnett's Lymond?

Reply

rachelmanija October 18 2011, 00:35:16 UTC
I'll take Antryg. Good choice.

Lymond, my God. Remind me of some of his high/low points? There's so much to work with, and I haven't re-read recently.

Reply

swan_tower October 18 2011, 00:38:09 UTC
I'm not sure how to describe Lymond without couching it in terms that amount to me armchair-diagnosing him myself -- but yeah, he was the first character I thought of.

Reply

rachelmanija October 18 2011, 00:40:17 UTC
Oh, no feel free to do that! You will count as supporting info from a friend of the patient with some psychological knowledge.

Are his migraines solely opium-related, or did he always have them?

Reply


swan_tower October 18 2011, 00:52:39 UTC
Also Howl, of Howl's Moving Castle (book, not movie). He's massively talented at magic, but also obsessed with dressing nicely and getting his toilette perfectly right, and serially picks up and then dumps girls once he's romanced them into falling in love with him. He slithers out of every kind of responsibility, and even lies to himself sometimes. He's really quite heartless, you know . . . .

Reply

rachelmanija October 18 2011, 01:28:43 UTC
HEE!

I need an Axis VI for fantasy characters: Condition occurring as a result of magic.

Reply

swan_tower October 18 2011, 04:13:57 UTC
That's an urban fantasy series concept right there, actually.

Reply

(The comment has been removed)


wordsofastory October 18 2011, 01:08:19 UTC
Tsuzuki, from Yami no Matsuei! Suicide attempts, major depressive episodes, possibly with PTSD flashbacks, either extreme emotional highs or pretending to have extreme emotional highs, use of food to deal with stress... and probably more I'm forgetting!

Reply

gaudior October 19 2011, 14:10:29 UTC
I did this one! With special bonus Hisoka! It was awesome!

Rachel, I am totally behind this exercise, as it is an excellent way to practice. Grin, yay.

Also fun: giving personality tests to fictional characters. Harry Potter did reasonably well on the MMPI...

Character suggestions...okay, you seem to have lots, and they're great, so I think I will leave it there. But yay!

Reply

rachelmanija October 19 2011, 19:14:19 UTC
Ha! I feel so much less weird now. ;)

Reply

gaudior October 19 2011, 20:06:30 UTC
No, not at all, I think you're spot-on. Because you're absolutely right that trying to diagnose real people is No Good when you're starting out, but also that you need practice thinking about three-dimensional, complex people and figuring out how they go with assessments and diagnoses and so forth.

Also, yay.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up