The ICON CRIT meme

[powercorrupts]

Anonymous icon critique meme

Do you ever wonder if there's something that you could improve with your icons, or have you ever wanted to tell someone that there's one thing that they do phenomenally, but you're afraid to leave a comment logged in? Do you just want a no-risk place to get icon concrit from, without the stress

Comments

[franchette]

franchette @ iconxlatte

[igumi]

Your icons are lovely ♥ also nice way in using textures :D
Mm.. maybe try using light textures? I haven't seen you using that so I think it'll add your variations 8D

[franchette]

thank you~ ♥
my bad habit is when I'm into some style, I abandoned the old one,
once I always used light texture, but nowdays, grey texture dominated me ^^;
anyway, thank you for you comment~ XD ^^ I'll do try use light texture more :D

[franchette]

your icons are beautiful!!
although I see you used too many texture but, your coloring is really good

[franchette]

♥♥ thank you~
T^T yessss...
when my eyes caught beautiful texture, I CAN'T HELP but want to use it T^T.
and unfortunately, it's TOO many.
and I know, it makes the icon somehow look too busy and over. ^^
I'll try to reduce ^^ thank you for the crits XD

[ryfee]

Your icons are pretty, my fav's gotta be #1. Simply beautiful; the textures and text and composition are just so good :)
I think you should try stronger coloring. Don't be afraid experimenting with colors. As for textures, try some light textures? Some of your icons may look over-sharpened so avoid using too high intensity; you could always fade it.

Keep up the good work!:)

[franchette]

♥ thank you~ XD but that's too by the help of 5 cm per second's graphic, it's AWESOME already 8D.
stronger? hm.. how stronger did you mean?
:D that's a 2nd ^^ I'll do :D
:O now you mentioned it, I realized it 80. thank you ♥

♥♥ thank you for the crits XD

[pamparumpum]

Gorgeous icons are gorgeous! :D I especially love #2

[franchette]

♥♥ why, thank you ^^

[senbonzakura77]

*points at second icon* Reason One why I love your icons. XD

Seriously, you use resources so flawlessly, and your cropping is wonderful. I really have no critiques - they're all stunning icons!

[franchette]

♥ before making that icons, I suddenly got the idea. it's suddenly appear in my mind ^^

aww.. thank you~ ♥

[overbreak]

*A* I always wonder how do you manage to sprout so splendidly made icons >.> *leers at her own icons and vomitting of the wickedness*
I love how you paint your icons with textures --so talented and fit-using :D thus I can't say it's over using.
The problem I probably want to squeal whine is that sometimes the color is too soft and need some strong side XD simply said, stronger color
beside that, I love your cropping, color opting, style and texture using! sometimes I just want to steal it and claim it as my own, oh my bad D: Mind to make tutorial?

PS: Gorgeous icon you're using! :D

[franchette]

♥ it's just selective color magic~
XD thank you ♥
O_o now you seconded ryfee, hm, how strong do you mean?
but, I guess, I love soft color better beacuse I can't do dark one :P
♥♥♥♥ thankssss
I can't make tutorial, really. I just don't know how.

[harumonic]

adsjf;lkajdslfk a franchetteee you rock SO BADLY OMG
especially #2 0___<

asdfj;lajsd YOU HAVE A GIFT, MY FRIEND.

[franchette]

many love #2 I guess ^^
XD thank youuu~~ ♥♥

♥♥♥ really? XD

[pamkips]

Your texture skillz are amazing and make me feel complete.
I seriously can not critic you XD