The ICON CRIT meme

[powercorrupts]

Anonymous icon critique meme

Do you ever wonder if there's something that you could improve with your icons, or have you ever wanted to tell someone that there's one thing that they do phenomenally, but you're afraid to leave a comment logged in? Do you just want a no-risk place to get icon concrit from, without the stress

Comments

[powercorrupts]

powercorrupts ∈ hanzaisha

[powercorrupts]

The coloring style and textures used in your icons are amazing, they always make me keysmash in one way or another.

[powercorrupts]

Jeez they're all stunning. Love the subtle textures and the original cropping, and number three is just beautiful all around.

[radarsparks]

radarsparks ♠ pantaloons

[radarsparks]

*-* ♥

[nebelpfade]

I can't tell you how to improve,because your icons are amazing as they are. I can only tell you to keep making more XD
♥!

[legality]

legality ❤ noisepop

[trojan]

I love your bright icons, like in the last two. They're beautiful. ♥

Your coloring is fabulous, I have no crit~.

[toukasa]

I always liked your choice of colors in icons and the unique areas of the picture you choose to icon, especially your fanart icons. I really like the perspective of your second icon there.
No particular crit for your icons. I think they're pretty awesome. ♥

[okay]

Sometimes a little brightness won't hurt anyone )8 I'm no icon expert but I really love the 4th icon, which is kind of a good example of what I'm talking about :) Overall, your icons are fabulous~♥

[bolshevists]

Curtissed ♫ CrystalCyanide

[nametag]

I absolutely adore your cropping but maybe you should play around with coloring a bit? I'm not completely sure how recent some of these icons are but #3 and #4 are just stunning.

[bolshevists]

I've been meaning to play around with coloring, since I basically use...the same technique for all of my icons. I need to experiment some more. Thank you for your comment! ♥

[bolshevists]

That Jade icon is beautiful. I love the colors fading out toward the end especially. The second icon would be nicer if the hues/saturation were played with.

One and eight don't look good with those particular textures you used. The first, I like the cropping but that texture just seems off.

Your coloring is improving, you just need to brighten them up a bit and not abuse the textures and I think you're fine.

[malkuths]

malkuths @ molested

[malkuths]

I like a lot of your cropping~ Sometimes, though, your icons come out a bit grainy--I'm looking at the third and the fourth one, mostly. Others are great, like the last two. I'd like to see more contrast, though. I think it'd add more depth, rather than looking like there's a film of sorts over your icons.

[malkuths]

Ah, thank you so much for your comment. I'll try my best to do better, and comments likes yours are exactly what I need to help me improve! I appreciate it soooo much ♥!

[malkuths]

I love your coloring and the use of textures~ Especially on the manga icons~ So cuteeee~ 8D