A Breath of Snow and Ashes Checkpoint 12

Oct 05, 2009 11:00

Now Discussing: Chapters 116 - The End
Assignment: Read Echo! We are discussing all of ABOSAA too. See List

Topic of the Week:
Brianna discovers William. What was your reaction and what did you think about Lord John’s explanations?

Thoughts and Topics... )

book: outlander-series, .discussions-book, ~book: 6-ashes

Leave a comment

Comments 3

(The comment has been removed)

sireesanwar October 8 2009, 22:28:47 UTC
I know and I have a feeling... William will be upset about that in the 8th book. John telling Bree why she couldn't say anything to William. All the stuff about him believing he's the 9th Earl and everyone else believing it.

1. Yeah though... nothing supposedly came of Dougal's death either.... Oh I'm loving the torture involved with Echo.

2. I think I read that and I agree. It was a big sacrifice and says a lot about how well John things of them.

3. It does seem a little convenient but I get she's tying some things up.

4. Hm. And I kind of saw it as him saying... "If you want to be there for them." Still I loved her reaction.

5. I tend to agree. I mean to put that decision on Jem. I mean a kid might start to think he hurt his grandda's feelings or something. I do understand that it was about Jem deciding whether or not he wanted to attempt the stones but still.

7. Me too and yet I have to wonder about it. Is there something special about Jamie too? I think Mandy has this!8. Yeah that is true but I still feel like if she was a ( ... )

Reply

(The comment has been removed)

sireesanwar October 9 2009, 20:05:07 UTC
Oh I hope so. That is what I want too ( ... )

Reply


Leave a comment

Up