Hello? People? It's Just One Day out of your whole life

Apr 09, 2008 10:20


Really, really creepy article in today's Guardian Women's Page on women gearing up for Their Big Day, i.e. wedding.

Okay, given my own marriage issues (I didn't even play weddings or lust for bride dolls as a child), perhaps I am never going to Get It on this kind of thing, but how spooky is it to make all this insane effort for something that is ( Read more... )

women's bodies, books, mass hysteria, marriage, internet booksellers, academic, bogglemen, archives, snarkiness, yonge

Leave a comment

Comments 52

m31andy April 9 2008, 09:43:40 UTC
Well there's that old quote (can't remember by whom, though) that marriage is what happens when a couple run out of things to say to each other...

Reply

oursin April 9 2008, 11:58:39 UTC
So they decide to have a big wedding, which will give them all these fun topics of discussion?

Reply

m31andy April 10 2008, 11:14:24 UTC
Absolutely. Eighteen months of arguing about table settings and hymns. And then, after the event, there's all the arguments about who's fault it was that Uncle Billy got *that* drunk and punched Michael from Accounting in the face.

Would keep a relationship going for years, that.

Reply

oursin April 10 2008, 11:52:20 UTC
'There was enough said at our Edie's wedding...'
Longlasting fun for all the family!

Reply


gillo April 9 2008, 11:08:32 UTC
I think the wedding is all about Performance - the one time in a girl's life when, however conditioned she is to patriarchal mores, she is not only entitled but expected to take centre stage, to be the focus of attention. Even for a shy, non-performer this is culturally conditioned - hence the whole "best day of your life" thing. And with any performance, "the readiness is all" - she has to do everything in her power to be as perfect, by her own standards and those of her peer group, as she can ever be.

Reply

mrissa April 9 2008, 11:32:33 UTC
This comment is probably dead on, and it makes me extremely grateful to come from a family where what the bride is expected to be is a good hostess, and anyone who was heard to wail that it was her special day would immediately be sat on by four aunties and a cousin.

I didn't play weddings or have bride dolls as a kid, either, and while I want to be careful, assuming we manage to have a kid, about not creating forbidden fruit issues, I think there will be a ban on bride dolls for this household's offspring as well. Any child of mine will have better things to dream about.

Reply

gillo April 9 2008, 16:19:25 UTC
Good luck with that. It's the ultimate dressing up game - it's either that or a "princess dress", which my six-year-old demanded. She's now 20 and still likes playing "dress-up".

anyone who was heard to wail that it was her special day would immediately be sat on by four aunties and a cousin.

Very much as it should be!

Reply

mrissa April 9 2008, 16:47:24 UTC
I object to princess play a good deal less than wedding play, in part because it took an extremely small nudge from my mother to tip my own "princess" into "fairy princess," and once I was a fairy princess, I might as well be a sorceress, which was like a fairy princess but potentially evil if she felt like it. Cue maniacal 4-year-old laughter here. And then you have the rest of my life.

Reply


(The comment has been removed)

oursin April 9 2008, 12:02:44 UTC
Yes, but if you're writing about the reasons why someone did what they did, and there are copious papers which surely provide significant clues if not outright mission statements en clair, it seems to me massively odd to work from secondary studies which were only skimming what's in the archive.

Reply


(The comment has been removed)

oursin April 9 2008, 12:03:59 UTC
Some while ago I had a (British) colleague who was RC and intending to save it for the wedding night, and was also doing the obsessive dieting thing.

Reply

heleninwales April 9 2008, 13:29:16 UTC
Both my son and my daughter had lived with their respective partners for a couple of years before they got married, so no, the sex part is not so likely to be an issue over here.

Reply


(The comment has been removed)

Re: random thoughts. better expressed in actual article but argh! must say stuff! oursin April 9 2008, 12:04:54 UTC
That whole thing about whether they can still fit in to the wedding dress... as if there would ever be any reason to do so.

And these days it's not just the photos, it's the video!

Reply

Re: random thoughts. better expressed in actual article but argh! must say stuff! moon_custafer April 9 2008, 18:09:34 UTC
and in a way the wedding is as much about the endless photos as anything else

That's why we took our own rather than hiring a professional photographer. We'd been to a couple of otherwise-enjoyable weddings in which the first hour of the reception consisted of waiting for the bride and groom to be released from the photo session so we could begin celebrating with them, or where the photographer wandered around trying to set up candid shots by making "humourous" comments like "Pretend you like each other."

Reply


Leave a comment

Up