So, officially a Manhunter convert, then? Very nice. It was a very good book. I can understand how the One Year Later gap would be confusing, though, if they don't even make a note of it.
In regards to the 90's heroes things, that's interesting, although part of me wonders if it's tied into Grant Morrison's Multiversity project. He mentioned that one of the books there would be dealing with a universe populated by the 90's characters, so it could be that they're letting them rest so that their portrayal there will be fresh.
gorgeous commish!scottyquickJune 22 2009, 14:59:51 UTC
Heh, yeah, that confused me SO MUCH. It was my first DC series, so I turned to Google because I was worried they'd left a few issues out of the trade. Then I was like " ... the hell? You could have spent an extra 9 words mentioning how the timeline's jumped ahead a year.". You'll LOVE the fourth trade, Andreyko writes really, really, REALLY good Diana.
Thanks for asking the Wondy and Connor question! I'm ... a bit terrified, really, but slightly hopeful Kyle might be one of those 90's characters, because I don't think Connor's interacted with any of them besides Kyle.
Aw, Young Avengers. The series that got me into Marvel and comics <3.
And there goes 50% of why I bother going to Newsarama. They're LYING LIARS WHO LIE!
Re: gorgeous commish!nevermore999June 22 2009, 16:56:10 UTC
Yeah, can't wait for Diana. I think what Bagley said was really rushed and confusing, so it's kinda understandable 'Rama misinterpreted it, according to Sattler.
Re: gorgeous commish!shanealtJune 22 2009, 17:01:47 UTC
The material in the fourth trade was really good, yeah. Some of it felt a bit fan-servicey, but the characterization was strong, and it felt like a nice, realistic extension to that part of Wonder Woman's character arc.
The fifth trade, unfortunately, wasn't as good--at least, not when I read it monthly. I love Gaydos, and I thought that his art would be perfect for Manhunter, but for some reason it just didn't fit--at least, not with the initial storyline that Andreyko chose to tell there. It probably would've been much better with the abortion storyline (that, unfortunately, probably won't ever be told), and with what little he got to draw of the final two issues. But I think that the first several issues in the fifth trade were the major weak point of the series.
Re: gorgeous commish!scottyquickJune 22 2009, 17:43:22 UTC
What do you mean by fanservicey?
I think that Matters of Choice might be told. Totally going to write a letter to DC, hinting that hey, know what might make a great OGN? Also, totally agree that Gaydos was a bad choice. He's a good artist, but a bad superhero artist. There's a reason why they didn't use him for action scenes in Alias, or why he was given the issue of New Avengers that focused upon Jessica and Luke's relationship.
Comments 9
In regards to the 90's heroes things, that's interesting, although part of me wonders if it's tied into Grant Morrison's Multiversity project. He mentioned that one of the books there would be dealing with a universe populated by the 90's characters, so it could be that they're letting them rest so that their portrayal there will be fresh.
Reply
Reply
Reply
Reply
Thanks for asking the Wondy and Connor question! I'm ... a bit terrified, really, but slightly hopeful Kyle might be one of those 90's characters, because I don't think Connor's interacted with any of them besides Kyle.
Aw, Young Avengers. The series that got me into Marvel and comics <3.
And there goes 50% of why I bother going to Newsarama. They're LYING LIARS WHO LIE!
Reply
Reply
The fifth trade, unfortunately, wasn't as good--at least, not when I read it monthly. I love Gaydos, and I thought that his art would be perfect for Manhunter, but for some reason it just didn't fit--at least, not with the initial storyline that Andreyko chose to tell there. It probably would've been much better with the abortion storyline (that, unfortunately, probably won't ever be told), and with what little he got to draw of the final two issues. But I think that the first several issues in the fifth trade were the major weak point of the series.
Reply
I think that Matters of Choice might be told. Totally going to write a letter to DC, hinting that hey, know what might make a great OGN? Also, totally agree that Gaydos was a bad choice. He's a good artist, but a bad superhero artist. There's a reason why they didn't use him for action scenes in Alias, or why he was given the issue of New Avengers that focused upon Jessica and Luke's relationship.
Reply
Leave a comment