First, a flash-animation parody even more frightening than the "taters" one: Gollum raps. (Dig the Orc in the bandanna.) Thanks to celticdave for finding that one
( Read more... )
...I'm happy to keep them separate.Amen. If I ever got the chance (or had the inclination) to speak with Sean about this, that's probably the thing I'd say in defense of slash writers: with a few random exceptions, most of us KNOW Tolkien didn't write Frodo and Sam as "gay" (though to be honest, I don't even like that term--even when I write slash, that's not how I see it. It's like what Rakshi said in one of her Sean/Elijah fics, in which Elijah and Ian were discussing Sean, and Ian commented: "I don't think Sean's gay. He just had the audacity to fall in love with his friend, who happened to be male." Which makes Sean's "Rosie Cotton" bit useless, because it's not that either one of them has a particular sexual standing. It's that they simply fell in love.). We know that subtext is only what we interpret it to be. But we write because we CAN feel that love between them--which is there no matter HOW you take it--and we WANT to look at it from another angle
( ... )
*nod nod* I know--does he really think the majority of Frodo-Sam-shippers are gay men? Hee. How naive, if so. (Which is what I thought at first too, but one learns quickly.)
In slash-verse, I view the Frodo/Sam possibility as a "fell in love with his friend" thing too, not a "Sam (or Frodo) is gay" thing. In Middle-Earth, I simply don't get the impression that "gay" is an option, as an identity, the way it is in modern life. As with most cultures until recent times, the notion of homosexuality may have referred to something people did, but not something people were.
Anyway, Sean doesn't seem to mind if we want to look at LOTR through slash-colored glasses. I cut a fair bit of his ramblings, but that was the point he was getting at: he doesn't wish to stand in the way of anyone's interpretation of, or interaction with, any story. A rare place where I'm with him 100% in this book. ;) (So far my main impression has been, "Dude. You must chill.")
In slash-verse, I view the Frodo/Sam possibility as a "fell in love with his friend" thing too, not a "Sam (or Frodo) is gay" thing.
I don't slash in the LotR world, but I do love Remus/Sirius, and that's the kinda relationship I see at least from Sirius's standpoint -- he's not really *gay*, certainly not flaming, but he just fell for one of his best friends. Remus I can see more as gay, hee.
And I second the snickering at the idea that most slashers are gay men. Hee. Silly Sean! ;)
Heehee - yes, I suppose Remus does seem a bit, er, lavender. But then he's British, so it's hard to tell. (Kidding, my UK friends! You know I love you.) The HP world, of course, is the modern world for the most part, so such labels might be more applicable. We can pretend we know what hobbits would think of such things, but it's all idle speculation since it's a fantasy realm, and Tolkien sure as heck never said. ;)
That's interesting that he brings that up in his book - although I suppose it is a rather unavoidable topic, haha :^D
I kind of wish it was seen like that in the modern real world; it'd be nice if people didn't label their sexuality. I mean, you could say "I'm usually attracted to the opposite sex" or "generally speaking, I like other men", but people didn't have to say "I'm gay" or "I'm straight". I think just loving who you happen to love is the way to go, and that is how I view slash.
I'm rather bewildered, however: does he think gay men write slash?
So far my main impression has been, "Dude. You must chill."
As I already said, right with ya there.
Okay, time for my take on slash! Yay! When I wrote/read Backstreet Boys slash fanfiction, some people would get really offended, saying, "They're not gay!" Duh. We know that (except maaaybe Howie. But that's another story). But the point is, my answer was always the same, "It's not an exploration of *their* sexuality, it's an exploration of *ours*." That's what it's all about, in the end. Our fantasies, not our theories. Therefore, no offense needs to be taken.
"It's not an exploration of *their* sexuality, it's an exploration of *ours*."
Very good way to put it. I've always been in favor of the simplest explanation, which in the case of slash is, "Two attractive guys are hotter than one." :) And thus, that's about us, not about them.
Comments 14
Reply
I know--does he really think the majority of Frodo-Sam-shippers are gay men? Hee. How naive, if so. (Which is what I thought at first too, but one learns quickly.)
In slash-verse, I view the Frodo/Sam possibility as a "fell in love with his friend" thing too, not a "Sam (or Frodo) is gay" thing. In Middle-Earth, I simply don't get the impression that "gay" is an option, as an identity, the way it is in modern life. As with most cultures until recent times, the notion of homosexuality may have referred to something people did, but not something people were.
Anyway, Sean doesn't seem to mind if we want to look at LOTR through slash-colored glasses. I cut a fair bit of his ramblings, but that was the point he was getting at: he doesn't wish to stand in the way of anyone's interpretation of, or interaction with, any story. A rare place where I'm with him 100% in this book. ;) (So far my main impression has been, "Dude. You must chill.")
Reply
I don't slash in the LotR world, but I do love Remus/Sirius, and that's the kinda relationship I see at least from Sirius's standpoint -- he's not really *gay*, certainly not flaming, but he just fell for one of his best friends. Remus I can see more as gay, hee.
And I second the snickering at the idea that most slashers are gay men. Hee. Silly Sean! ;)
Reply
Reply
I kind of wish it was seen like that in the modern real world; it'd be nice if people didn't label their sexuality. I mean, you could say "I'm usually attracted to the opposite sex" or "generally speaking, I like other men", but people didn't have to say "I'm gay" or "I'm straight". I think just loving who you happen to love is the way to go, and that is how I view slash.
I'm rather bewildered, however: does he think gay men write slash?
*chuckles* if only he knew...
Reply
Reply
As I already said, right with ya there.
Okay, time for my take on slash! Yay! When I wrote/read Backstreet Boys slash fanfiction, some people would get really offended, saying, "They're not gay!" Duh. We know that (except maaaybe Howie. But that's another story). But the point is, my answer was always the same, "It's not an exploration of *their* sexuality, it's an exploration of *ours*." That's what it's all about, in the end. Our fantasies, not our theories. Therefore, no offense needs to be taken.
Reply
Very good way to put it. I've always been in favor of the simplest explanation, which in the case of slash is, "Two attractive guys are hotter than one." :) And thus, that's about us, not about them.
Reply
Reply
Reply
Leave a comment