Ядерный геном неандертальцев - старт дешифровки
New DNA Test Is Yielding Clues to Neanderthals
By NICHOLAS WADE
The archaic human species that dominated Europe until 30,000 years ago is about to emerge from the shadows. With the help of a new DNA sequencing machine that operates with firefly light, the bones of the Neanderthals have begun to tell their story to geneticists.
One million units of Neanderthal DNA have already been analyzed, and a draft version of the entire genome, 3.2 billion units in length, should be ready in two years, said Dr. Svante Paabo, the leader of the research project at the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology in Leipzig, Germany.
Biologists expect knowledge of the Neanderthal genome to reveal, by its differences with the human genome, many distinctive qualities of what it means to be human. Researchers also hope to resolve such questions as whether the Neanderthals spoke, their hair and skin color, and whether they interbred at all with the modern humans who first arrived on their doorstep 45,000 years ago, or were driven to extinction without leaving any genetic legacy.
Dr. Paabo has shared some of his precious sample of Neanderthal DNA with Edward M. Rubin of the Joint Genome Institute in Walnut Creek, Calif., whose team has identified 62,250 units of Neanderthal DNA by a different method. The two teams report their results in this week’s issues of the journals Nature and Science respectively, saying they have independently demonstrated that recovery of the Neanderthal genome is now possible.
From the data so far, Dr. Rubin’s team reports that the Neanderthal and human genomes are at least 99.5 percent identical. Dr. Paabo’s team has calculated that the “effective” size of the founding Neanderthal population was about 3,000, corresponding to a census size of fewer than 10,000 individuals. Both teams say it now seems much more unlikely that modern humans and Neanderthals interbred, though the possibility cannot yet be excluded.
“I think these results are monumental,” said Richard G. Klein, a paleoanthropologist at Stanford University who was not involved in the studies. The full Neanderthal genome will resolve many longstanding issues about Neanderthals and their relationship to modern humans, including their physical and perhaps behavioral differences, he said.
The Neanderthals, who flourished for some 400,000 years before their extinction about 30,000 years ago, physically resembled modern humans, but the middle of their face jutted forward and their large brain case had a distinctive bulge or bun at the back. They were heavily muscled and presumably well adapted to the cold conditions of the last ice age. They may well have been terrifying to the lighter-boned modern humans who first encountered them, except that their weapons were considerably less advanced. The Neanderthals still used a million-year-old stone tool kit that modern humans abandoned 5,000 years before they encountered the Neanderthals.
Archaeologists have shown that as the first modern humans, known as the Aurignacian culture, moved westward across Europe, the Neanderthals receded in parallel. By 30,000 years ago or even earlier, the Aurignacian conquest of Europe was complete and the Neanderthals had disappeared from their last refuges in what are now Spain and Portugal.
Dr. Paabo began his quest for Neanderthal DNA more than a decade ago, and has had to overcome a daunting array of obstacles. Many extravagant claims were then being made about DNA in old bones, with some scientists claiming to have recovered DNA from dinosaur bones millions of years old. But such bones were often contaminated by the DNA of the people who handled them, and Dr. Paabo saved the field from disrepute by demonstrating the extreme precautions necessary to avoid analyzing human DNA by mistake.
In 1997 he succeeded in analyzing part of the Neanderthal mitochondrial DNA, showing that it differed profoundly from modern human DNA. Mitochondria, the small organelles that provide the cell’s energy, are separate from the main genome in the cell’s nucleus. Since the nuclear DNA in old bones is degraded into millions of short fragments, 50 or so units in length, it seemed beyond hope of retrieval.
But recently a new kind of DNA sequencing machine was invented. Made by 454 Life Sciences of Branford, Conn., it prompts each DNA unit to generate a flash of light by stimulating the firefly enzyme luciferase. The flashes are captured by the same sort of image-sensing plate used in telescopes to capture starlight. From the timing and position of the flashes, a computer reconstructs the sequence of the DNA units. The kind of DNA the 454 machine works best with are tiny fragments the size of those found in old bones.
Dr. Paabo then scoured the museums of Europe for Neanderthal bones that might still retain DNA. Most of the 70 he tested had none, since DNA quickly degrades after the death of the organism. Many others were heavily contaminated with DNA from the curators and scientists who had handled them. Since human DNA is almost identical to Neanderthal DNA, the contamination posed serious problems.
Just one bone, retrieved from the Vindija cave in Croatia, turned out to retain DNA and be fairly free of human contamination. Asked at a news conference what made it so special, Dr. Paabo said that because it was small and uninteresting it had been “thrown in a big box of uninformative bones in the museum in Zagreb and wasn’t handled very much.”
The owner of the Vindija bone was a male Neanderthal who died about 38,000 years ago. As with other ancient bones, most of the surviving DNA belongs to the bacteria that consumed it when fresh. Less than 6 percent is Neanderthal DNA, and this has suffered a chemical degradation of the four DNA bases, referred to as A, T, G and C, whereby some of the C’s are converted to T’s and some G’s to A’s. Dr. Paabo has developed methods for distinguishing the real Neanderthal DNA and addressing the chemical conversion problem.
Dr. Paabo hopes to find other Neanderthal bones with retrievable DNA. But even if no more turn up, he believes there is enough DNA in the Vindija bone alone to complete a draft of the full Neanderthal genome.
He and his team still have many more problems to overcome, but other researchers are impressed with the progress so far. “He’s superbright and superthoughtful, and if anyone’s ever going to do it, it’s him,” Dr. Klein said.
If the full Neanderthal genome is retrieved, biologists may be able to ask if the Neanderthals had language by looking at their version of the human gene known as FOXP2, thought to be one of the last components to evolve in mediating the modern human language faculty. FOXP2 has changed significantly since the human lineage split apart from that of chimps some six million years ago. If the Neanderthal version resembles the chimp version, that would make it less likely they had modern, syntactical language.
The Neanderthal genome should also enable biologists to calculate which aspects of human evolution took place between 6 million and 500,000 years ago, and which are more recent. The latter is the approximate date at which the Neanderthal and human lineages split apart. Dr. Paabo also believes the Neanderthal genome will help geneticists identify which human genes have been subject to the pressures of natural selection in the last 500,000 years. This would be of great interest in identifying the distinctive genetic attributes of modern humans.
From the data already obtained, Dr. Paabo and his colleagues estimate that the ancestral Neanderthal population was very small, perhaps fewer than 10,000 individuals. Since the ancestral population of modern humans was much the same size, it seems that all populations of early humans were tiny, expanding only after the ice age ended.
From the data gathered so far by Dr. Paabo’s and Dr. Rubin’s teams, there is no evidence of interbreeding between Neanderthals and modern humans. But the possibility of a small amount of genetic interchange cannot yet be ruled out. Dr. Bruce T. Lahn, a geneticist at the University of Chicago, published a report earlier this month suggesting that one of the two principal versions of the human gene for microcephalin, which helps determine brain size, came from an archaic population, presumably the Neanderthals.
So far neither team has analyzed enough Neanderthal DNA to test Dr. Lahn’s proposal.
By NICHOLAS WADE
The archaic human species that dominated Europe until 30,000 years ago is about to emerge from the shadows. With the help of a new DNA sequencing machine that operates with firefly light, the bones of the Neanderthals have begun to tell their story to geneticists.
One million units of Neanderthal DNA have already been analyzed, and a draft version of the entire genome, 3.2 billion units in length, should be ready in two years, said Dr. Svante Paabo, the leader of the research project at the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology in Leipzig, Germany.
Biologists expect knowledge of the Neanderthal genome to reveal, by its differences with the human genome, many distinctive qualities of what it means to be human. Researchers also hope to resolve such questions as whether the Neanderthals spoke, their hair and skin color, and whether they interbred at all with the modern humans who first arrived on their doorstep 45,000 years ago, or were driven to extinction without leaving any genetic legacy.
Dr. Paabo has shared some of his precious sample of Neanderthal DNA with Edward M. Rubin of the Joint Genome Institute in Walnut Creek, Calif., whose team has identified 62,250 units of Neanderthal DNA by a different method. The two teams report their results in this week’s issues of the journals Nature and Science respectively, saying they have independently demonstrated that recovery of the Neanderthal genome is now possible.
From the data so far, Dr. Rubin’s team reports that the Neanderthal and human genomes are at least 99.5 percent identical. Dr. Paabo’s team has calculated that the “effective” size of the founding Neanderthal population was about 3,000, corresponding to a census size of fewer than 10,000 individuals. Both teams say it now seems much more unlikely that modern humans and Neanderthals interbred, though the possibility cannot yet be excluded.
“I think these results are monumental,” said Richard G. Klein, a paleoanthropologist at Stanford University who was not involved in the studies. The full Neanderthal genome will resolve many longstanding issues about Neanderthals and their relationship to modern humans, including their physical and perhaps behavioral differences, he said.
The Neanderthals, who flourished for some 400,000 years before their extinction about 30,000 years ago, physically resembled modern humans, but the middle of their face jutted forward and their large brain case had a distinctive bulge or bun at the back. They were heavily muscled and presumably well adapted to the cold conditions of the last ice age. They may well have been terrifying to the lighter-boned modern humans who first encountered them, except that their weapons were considerably less advanced. The Neanderthals still used a million-year-old stone tool kit that modern humans abandoned 5,000 years before they encountered the Neanderthals.
Archaeologists have shown that as the first modern humans, known as the Aurignacian culture, moved westward across Europe, the Neanderthals receded in parallel. By 30,000 years ago or even earlier, the Aurignacian conquest of Europe was complete and the Neanderthals had disappeared from their last refuges in what are now Spain and Portugal.
Dr. Paabo began his quest for Neanderthal DNA more than a decade ago, and has had to overcome a daunting array of obstacles. Many extravagant claims were then being made about DNA in old bones, with some scientists claiming to have recovered DNA from dinosaur bones millions of years old. But such bones were often contaminated by the DNA of the people who handled them, and Dr. Paabo saved the field from disrepute by demonstrating the extreme precautions necessary to avoid analyzing human DNA by mistake.
In 1997 he succeeded in analyzing part of the Neanderthal mitochondrial DNA, showing that it differed profoundly from modern human DNA. Mitochondria, the small organelles that provide the cell’s energy, are separate from the main genome in the cell’s nucleus. Since the nuclear DNA in old bones is degraded into millions of short fragments, 50 or so units in length, it seemed beyond hope of retrieval.
But recently a new kind of DNA sequencing machine was invented. Made by 454 Life Sciences of Branford, Conn., it prompts each DNA unit to generate a flash of light by stimulating the firefly enzyme luciferase. The flashes are captured by the same sort of image-sensing plate used in telescopes to capture starlight. From the timing and position of the flashes, a computer reconstructs the sequence of the DNA units. The kind of DNA the 454 machine works best with are tiny fragments the size of those found in old bones.
Dr. Paabo then scoured the museums of Europe for Neanderthal bones that might still retain DNA. Most of the 70 he tested had none, since DNA quickly degrades after the death of the organism. Many others were heavily contaminated with DNA from the curators and scientists who had handled them. Since human DNA is almost identical to Neanderthal DNA, the contamination posed serious problems.
Just one bone, retrieved from the Vindija cave in Croatia, turned out to retain DNA and be fairly free of human contamination. Asked at a news conference what made it so special, Dr. Paabo said that because it was small and uninteresting it had been “thrown in a big box of uninformative bones in the museum in Zagreb and wasn’t handled very much.”
The owner of the Vindija bone was a male Neanderthal who died about 38,000 years ago. As with other ancient bones, most of the surviving DNA belongs to the bacteria that consumed it when fresh. Less than 6 percent is Neanderthal DNA, and this has suffered a chemical degradation of the four DNA bases, referred to as A, T, G and C, whereby some of the C’s are converted to T’s and some G’s to A’s. Dr. Paabo has developed methods for distinguishing the real Neanderthal DNA and addressing the chemical conversion problem.
Dr. Paabo hopes to find other Neanderthal bones with retrievable DNA. But even if no more turn up, he believes there is enough DNA in the Vindija bone alone to complete a draft of the full Neanderthal genome.
He and his team still have many more problems to overcome, but other researchers are impressed with the progress so far. “He’s superbright and superthoughtful, and if anyone’s ever going to do it, it’s him,” Dr. Klein said.
If the full Neanderthal genome is retrieved, biologists may be able to ask if the Neanderthals had language by looking at their version of the human gene known as FOXP2, thought to be one of the last components to evolve in mediating the modern human language faculty. FOXP2 has changed significantly since the human lineage split apart from that of chimps some six million years ago. If the Neanderthal version resembles the chimp version, that would make it less likely they had modern, syntactical language.
The Neanderthal genome should also enable biologists to calculate which aspects of human evolution took place between 6 million and 500,000 years ago, and which are more recent. The latter is the approximate date at which the Neanderthal and human lineages split apart. Dr. Paabo also believes the Neanderthal genome will help geneticists identify which human genes have been subject to the pressures of natural selection in the last 500,000 years. This would be of great interest in identifying the distinctive genetic attributes of modern humans.
From the data already obtained, Dr. Paabo and his colleagues estimate that the ancestral Neanderthal population was very small, perhaps fewer than 10,000 individuals. Since the ancestral population of modern humans was much the same size, it seems that all populations of early humans were tiny, expanding only after the ice age ended.
From the data gathered so far by Dr. Paabo’s and Dr. Rubin’s teams, there is no evidence of interbreeding between Neanderthals and modern humans. But the possibility of a small amount of genetic interchange cannot yet be ruled out. Dr. Bruce T. Lahn, a geneticist at the University of Chicago, published a report earlier this month suggesting that one of the two principal versions of the human gene for microcephalin, which helps determine brain size, came from an archaic population, presumably the Neanderthals.
So far neither team has analyzed enough Neanderthal DNA to test Dr. Lahn’s proposal.