Warnings: Not for Sirius Black fans.

Apr 24, 2006 08:38


Part (3)
Title: How innocent was Sirius Black?
Spoilers: Prisoner of Azkaban (PoA), The Order of the Phoenix (OotP)
Summary: This is a multi part (3) piece.
Beta by my ever wonderful "cho_sa" 
A/N: I would very much appreciate it if you do not go after my blood/head/or any other part of my physiology. A/N2: I would like to thank
Read more... )

Leave a comment

courtaud April 24 2006, 09:24:40 UTC
Here via HP_Theories. Hope you don't mind.

• “Harry went right after Black, who was making Snape drift along ahead of them; he kept bumping his lolling head on the low ceiling.”
Thank you for pointing out this. I was under the impression that everybody find this an acceptable behaviour, even if no one of the 'good' people in the Shrieking Shack found the time to check out someone who was bleeding from the head and inconscious for quite a long time. Bumping his head again and again could have finished him.

Oh yes. Great offences indeed. This, ‘Sneaking around’ and ‘Trying to find out what we where up to’, sounds very dangerous to their well being.
They were doing things who could have gained them expulsion, no doubt. But at the time of the Prank it was not such a disaster. All of them had their OWLS, so they could perform magic and find a job. BUT. Aside letting a werewolf running free without danger to them (because werewolves don't do animals) and having more than one time a 'close call', as Lupin says (it is, he came really ( ... )

Reply

courtaud April 24 2006, 14:47:25 UTC
Because he's a super dog!
How could I not think of that! *feels silly*

Then I don't like Lily anymore.
I have a feeling that we will see a lot of her in the last book.
Anyway JKR has made richly clear that a woman is allowed strategy for catching her man: look at Ginny! And rightly so, because if a woman fail to catch him she would waste away: look at Tonks!

The Lexicon is useful to anyone who wants to check the data to back up their theories with canon. JKR uses it!

Thanks. But I don't want to see it.
Why? Climbing the Black family tree is an healty exercise!
If we choose to consider it as 'canon', it shows a lot about the background of Sirius (I'm trying to keep the topic on Sirius because i'm still scared). And by the way, do you think that Sirius is the kind of guy who makes a will? At thirty-five? And gives it to Dumbledore to keep?

Reply

menolike April 24 2006, 15:06:10 UTC
I'm trying to keep the topic on Sirius because i'm still scared

Nice save. But I'm watching you.

*glares*

Reply

pervert_bitch April 24 2006, 20:28:50 UTC
Regarding Sirius will... maybe...
1. Sirius finally realises he is a reckless ... and was aware of his own mortality.
2. Maybe because the order is a dangerous job it is a prerequisite of all order members to have wills... just in case :P

Reply

menolike April 24 2006, 22:24:13 UTC
Sirius finally realises he is a reckless

*Laughs very hard*

Reply

mugglegirl0908 May 5 2006, 05:01:09 UTC
There is a 'HP-Lexicon?'
(this has went beyond 'way too much')

Thanks. But I don't want to see it.

Out of curiosity, why? Taking a look around the HP Lexicon would seriously help your canon debating skills. It is a HUGE reference site where you could check canon facts before post fics and essays. It places everything we know about every character, place, and event into one easy and accessible format.

You may want to try it out. It would help with distinguishing between what you want to be true and what is canon fact. Always helpful when posting theories based on a body of works like the HP series ( ... )

Reply


Leave a comment

Up